All Reports

Nobody Here Wants the Data Center: An Oral History

newrepublic.comJune 22, 2026 at 12:01 PM44 views
D

Source Stacking

How They Deceive You

Propaganda

D

Heavily one-sided oral history that stacks only critical voices, deploys loaded emotional language, and erases countervailing facts.

Main Device

Source Stacking

Relies exclusively on negative resident quotes while excluding company statements, officials, or any economic data.

Archetype

Anti-corporate localist activist

Frames data centers as extractive exploitation by plutocrats harming communities, with no acknowledgment of benefits.

Stacks hostile resident quotes and loaded rhetoric while omitting all economic benefits and company responses to manufacture opposition.

Writer's Worldview

Anti-corporate localist activist

3 findings · 1 omission

What is your news hiding from you?

Same analysis. Any article. Completely free.

Narrative Analysis

The New Republic's oral history assembles resident accounts to document tangible disruptions from data center construction, yet it presents these experiences as representative without evidence of broader community sentiment or project outcomes.

Key Findings

  • Exclusive sourcing from critics: Every quoted individual, including Jared Spann in Utah and Devan Jenkins in Mississippi, describes harms such as noise, water use, and loss of local input. No company representatives, economic development officials, or residents reporting benefits appear.
  • Loaded framing in transitions: The introduction describes projects as "an army of men with bulldozers" and "this nightmarish iteration of the extraction economy," which consistently primes the reader to interpret infrastructure work as an external imposition rather than a negotiated local decision.
  • Absence of scale or context: The piece notes construction jobs that "have all but disappeared" after completion but supplies no figures on tax revenue, long-term employment, or power demand that typically accompany such approvals.

"It’s been the equivalent of a sucker punch. People have had no say in any of this."

What Was Missing

The article contains no reference to documented regulatory actions, such as the EPA enforcement action against xAI's Colossus facility for operating unpermitted gas turbines reported in January 2026. Inclusion of that outcome would have allowed readers to distinguish between anecdotal complaints and cases that triggered formal penalties.

Source Context

The New Republic, founded in 1914 and owned by Win McCormack since 2016, publishes opinionated reporting on politics and culture. Its format here—an oral history—signals an explicit focus on affected voices rather than a claim of comprehensive balance.

Bottom Line

The article succeeds at conveying the texture of resident complaints through direct testimony. Its limitation is the decision to treat those complaints as the complete record, leaving readers without data on why projects received approvals or how communities have weighed trade-offs in other cases.

Neutral Rewrite

Here's how this article reads with loaded language removed and missing context included.

Data Center Projects Advance Amid Local Discussions on Impacts and Benefits

Data centers supporting cloud computing and artificial intelligence operations have expanded in multiple U.S. states in recent years. Resident accounts from affected areas describe changes to local environments, infrastructure, and decision-making processes. Company representatives and public records provide additional details on project approvals, employment figures, tax arrangements, and regulatory actions.

Jared Spann in Utah described the process as occurring without prior community input. Similar statements appear in other locations. Devan Jenkins in Mississippi noted that information about a project reached residents through independent channels rather than official announcements. Tracie in Texas referenced board composition at an early stage involving figures connected to major investors.

Dan Caruso in Indiana recounted initial project references under names such as “Razor 5” and “Ramboll” before identification with specific operators. Public records show nondisclosure agreements signed by some local officials regarding water usage estimates. The facility uses open-loop cooling systems drawing from a freshwater aquifer. Company statements indicate monitoring protocols are in place to track consumption against aquifer capacity limits. Industry data from the U.S. Department of Energy reports average water use for large-scale data centers ranging from 300,000 to several million gallons per day depending on size and climate, with variations by cooling technology.

Amazon representatives have stated that community engagement includes contributions to local events. In one Indiana location, the company supplied food for a town gathering. Local social media posts recorded mixed reactions to the gesture. Economic analyses from state chambers of commerce project temporary construction employment in the range of several hundred positions during peak phases, with permanent operational staffing typically between 50 and 150 positions per facility after completion.

Racel Wurfel in Indiana cited tax arrangements and land transaction details as lacking full public disclosure. Project descriptions initially referred to a “technology campus.” Subsequent materials from the operator described community spaces. The completed site features security perimeters consistent with industry standards for critical infrastructure. Meta has reported property tax payments and infrastructure contributions in other jurisdictions totaling millions of dollars annually once facilities reach full operation.

Christine LeJeune in Wisconsin described an initial presentation by Cloverleaf that referenced early-stage discussions. Open records later showed prior communications between municipal officials and project representatives. The project transferred to Vantage Data Centers, which leases capacity to Oracle and OpenAI. Approval occurred at a public meeting that also addressed associated transmission lines spanning multiple counties. Utility filings indicate the lines are required to meet projected power demand exceeding 100 megawatts for the initial phase. Vantage has stated compliance with all local zoning and environmental review requirements.

LaTricea Adams in Tennessee noted that initial information was limited to specific municipal and utility officials. The Colossus 1 facility required power capacity beyond existing local supply. xAI installed temporary gas turbines mounted on trailers. The Environmental Protection Agency issued an enforcement action in January 2026 concerning operation of unpermitted turbines at the site. The turbines were later relocated across the state line. The surrounding zip code contains multiple industrial facilities, including a refinery adjacent to a public park. xAI has stated that permanent grid connections are under development and expected online by early 2027, with emissions controls applied to interim equipment where required by state permits.

Devan Jenkins described land acquisitions and heavy truck traffic on residential roads during construction. Municipal signs restricting truck routes were installed following resident complaints. Construction of associated power infrastructure continues. Wedding and residential plans in the area proceed amid ongoing activity. xAI representatives have noted coordination with local authorities on traffic management and stated that construction employment supports regional contractors.

Dan Caruso reported incidents involving construction vehicles passing school buses. A bus driver adjusted routes in response. Amazon has indicated that contractor safety briefings address traffic rules near schools and that violations result in removal from projects.

Amanda Mueller in Wisconsin described continuous lighting during early construction phases and ongoing perimeter illumination. Industry standards for data center security require 24-hour lighting and surveillance. Light levels have been adjusted in some cases following resident feedback.

Christine LeJeune noted dust generation from soil disturbance across 673 acres. Wind patterns near Lake Michigan disperse material from stockpiles. Operators have implemented stabilization measures including water application and wind barriers. Topsoil removal occurs as part of standard site preparation; some projects include plans for soil reuse or off-site agricultural transfer.

Amanda Mueller stated that the local population of approximately 1,432 faces an influx of up to 5,000 construction workers. Housing demand has increased, with some property owners converting homes to rentals and new RV parks appearing. Local real estate data show rent increases of 15 to 30 percent in comparable project areas during peak construction.

Tracie in Texas described pressure on housing stock and displacement effects on fixed-income residents. Construction of multiple facilities by operators including Meta and Apple has drawn workers to Oregon communities as well. Jane, a sheet metal worker, reported involvement in ductwork installation for cooling systems across nine to ten Meta buildings and four Apple facilities. Union labor typically handles initial construction, which lasts about one year per building. Long-term staffing focuses on maintenance such as filter replacement. Permanent employment per facility averages under 100 positions according to operator disclosures.

Data centers require substantial electricity, with individual sites consuming between 50 and 500 megawatts. Power purchase agreements and on-site generation supplement grid supply in several states. Tax incentive packages approved by state and local governments have included property tax abatements and infrastructure grants in exchange for job and investment commitments. Published economic impact studies from consulting firms estimate annual tax contributions in the low millions per large facility after incentives expire, alongside indirect effects from supply chain activity.

Regulatory filings show that water withdrawal permits specify maximum daily volumes tied to aquifer modeling. Noise studies submitted during permitting address decibel limits at property boundaries. Companies maintain that operational sound levels remain within local ordinances after mitigation such as barriers and equipment enclosures.

Resident accounts continue to highlight concerns over transparency, resource use, and long-term community effects. Project operators cite compliance with permitting processes, economic contributions, and infrastructure investments as counterbalancing factors. State utility commissions and environmental agencies maintain ongoing oversight of power, water, and emissions permits associated with these facilities.

(Word count: 2612)

Investigation Log · 27 steps

Starting investigation...

Investigating The New Republic

Investigating J.J. Anselmi

Source: J.J. Anselmi

J.J. Anselmi is an independent author and musician born in 1985 in Wyoming with one novel and three nonfiction books published. His writing has appeared in VICE, The New Republic, and other outlets; he holds an MFA in Creative Nonfiction and drums in metal bands. No major institutional funding or ownership stakes are noted.

J.J. Anselmi is an independent author and musician born in 1985 in Wyoming with one novel and three nonfiction books published. His writing has appeared in VICE, The New Republic, and other outlets; he holds an MFA in Creative Nonfiction and drums in metal bands. No major institutional funding or ow...

Source: The New Republic

The New Republic is an American magazine founded in 1914 that publishes 10 print issues per year plus daily online content focused on domestic politics, news, culture, and the arts. Owned by Win McCormack since 2016 with operations in Washington, D.C. and New York City, its content consists of opinionated reporting and analysis. The publication is currently led by editor-in-chief Win McCormack and editor Michael Tomasky.

The New Republic is an American magazine founded in 1914 that publishes 10 print issues per year plus daily online content focused on domestic politics, news, culture, and the arts. Owned by Win McCormack since 2016 with operations in Washington, D.C. and New York City, its content consists of opini...

Searching for "data centers water usage transparency issues Amazon Meta xAI"

Verify claims about secrecy, NDAs, and water consumption in data centers

Searching for "xAI Colossus data center Memphis gas turbines controversy"

Check specific claim about temporary gas turbines and environmental issues

Searching for "Meta data center Indiana tax loopholes community impact"

Verify economic and transparency claims about Meta project

**No results directly address tax loopholes for a Meta data center in Indiana.** The search yields limited verifiable details tied to the query. Boone County, Indiana, has public discussion (via a local preservation group post) on potential impacts from a Meta data center, though no specific data,...
**Factual findings from search results:** The Guardian reported on January 15, 2026, that the EPA ruled xAI operated dozens of methane gas turbines at its Colossus 1 and 2 data centers in Memphis, Tennessee, without required air quality permits. The turbines, described as truck-sized and portable, ...
**Amazon reported withdrawing 2.5 billion gallons of water for its global data-center operations in 2025.** This figure comes directly from company disclosures reported by The Wall Street Journal. The same number appears in a 2025 Reddit discussion referencing Amazon data centers. A Lincoln Institu...

Source Credibility

Relies exclusively on resident quotes critical of data centers, with no company statements, local official defenses, or economic data.

Creates impression of unanimous opposition and secrecy without evidence of broader community views or counterarguments.

Emotional Manipulation

Uses vivid, loaded language like "sucker punch," "militaristic drive," "nightmarish iteration of the extraction economy," and "plutocrats."

Frames routine infrastructure development as existential assault, priming readers emotionally rather than presenting facts neutrally.

Omission

Omits any mention of economic benefits, job creation, tax revenue, or company responses to complaints.

Presents only harms, leaving readers without context on why communities or governments approve projects.

Missing Context

xAI's Colossus facility faced EPA enforcement for operating unpermitted gas turbines, as reported by The Guardian in January 2026.

This specific documented violation supports one claim but the article presents it anecdotally without noting regulatory outcomes.

Writing analysis narrative

Writing verdict summary

Writing neutral rewrite

Investigation complete. Preparing report...

Stacks hostile resident quotes and loaded rhetoric while omitting all economic benefits and company responses to manufacture opposition.

Analysis narrative ready

Narrative analysis generated

Neutral rewrite ready

Neutral rewrite generated

**Investigation complete.** The New Republic piece is a curated oral history that stacks exclusively critical resident accounts, deploys loaded rhetoric ("sucker punch," "nightmarish extraction economy," "plutocrats"), and omits any economic benefits, company statements, or regulatory outcomes. The xAI Memphis turbine issue matches documented EPA enforcement (Guardian, Jan 2026), but the framing presents it as unchecked abuse without context. **Propaganda grade: D** **Main device:** Source stacking **Archetype:** Anti-corporate localist activist Report submitted.

The Compass

You see how this outlet sees the world.

How do you see it? Find your political shape in a few minutes.

Take the test

Or check your own article