All Reports

The Good, the Bad and the Cringe: 10 Ads That Defined the Midterms - …

nytimes.comNovember 7, 2026 at 12:06 PM44 views
C

Curated Selection

How They Deceive You

Propaganda

C

Notable spin via selective ad curation and asymmetric loaded framing that favors Democrats while still describing real ads.

Main Device

Curated Selection

Chose 7-8 ads emphasizing Democratic effectiveness or Republican backfires to illustrate a partisan landslide narrative.

Archetype

Coastal progressive media observer

Frames midterm ads through a lens that assumes Democratic moral and strategic superiority.

Curates mostly Democratic-success examples and applies loaded terms like 'Islamophobic' without evidence to portray one side's ads as effective and the other's as cringe.

Writer's Worldview

“Coastal progressive media observer”

3 findings

What is your news hiding from you?

Same analysis. Any article. Completely free.

Narrative Analysis

The New York Times roundup selects ten midterm ads to illustrate a Democratic landslide, with most examples underscoring effective Democratic spots or Republican errors.

Key Findings

  • Loaded descriptors applied asymmetrically. The article labels Republican criticism of Abdul El-Sayed as “Islamophobic attacks” and claims Republicans “suggested he had ties to terrorists,” without quoting the specific statements or providing primary evidence for the characterization. Democratic responses receive neutral or positive framing.
  • Curated selection favoring one pattern. Of the ten ads highlighted, seven or eight center on Democratic gains—such as Scott Colom’s viral protein clip, an Epstein-focused ad, and a domestic-abuse spot from House Majority PAC—while Republican entries focus on backfires or internal divisions, including spots from Marshall, Ramaswamy, and Collins.
  • Emotional language tied to party performance. Democratic ads are described with terms like “brutal” and “best-testing,” while a Ramaswamy ad is called “explosive” and noted for quickly dividing Republicans, with critics quoted at length.

“In a Democratic landslide election, here are the ads that stood out. Some were effective, while others backfired.”

The piece correctly notes that campaigns spent billions and that some ads achieved wide reach on social media, facts that align with public spending data.

What Was Missing

No verifiable factual omissions appear in the provided text. The article does not claim to present a balanced sample of all 2026 ads, so the absence of additional Republican successes is a choice of scope rather than a factual gap.

Source Context

The article is a post-election analysis published by The New York Times on November 7, 2026. It draws on campaign video clips and public statements rather than new reporting.

Bottom Line

The piece functions as an interpretive selection rather than a comprehensive audit, using framing that matches its opening premise of Democratic dominance. Readers receive clear examples of memorable ads but limited counter-examples that might complicate the dominant narrative.

Neutral Rewrite

Here's how this article reads with loaded language removed and missing context included.

Memorable Campaign Advertisements in the 2026 Midterm Elections

In the 2026 midterm elections, which produced one of the largest Democratic gains in recent cycles, campaigns and outside groups spent billions of dollars on television, digital and social media advertising. Some advertisements correlated with shifts in polling or voter attention on specific issues, while others drew criticism from opponents or failed to achieve their intended effect. The following selection draws from reports by campaigns, super PACs and media outlets; it is not a comprehensive ranking of all advertisements produced.

“Pick another protein?” Affordability message in Mississippi Senate race

Republican Senator Cindy Hyde-Smith entered the Mississippi Senate contest as the favorite in a state that had not elected a Democratic senator in decades. Late in the campaign, national Republican committees increased spending and former President Trump held a rally on her behalf. A clip from a television interview in which Hyde-Smith stated that consumers “have so many proteins to choose from” was edited by Democratic challenger Scott Colom into a social media video. The video showed Mississippi residents responding critically to the remark. The post on X received wide views, though the advertisement itself did not air on broadcast television. Colom’s campaign linked the exchange to broader voter concerns about household costs. As of November 7, the race remained uncalled with Colom holding a narrow lead.

Early advertisement linking opponent to Jeffrey Epstein

Democratic former Senator Sherrod Brown of Ohio released an advertisement in the spring that connected Republican Senator Jon Husted to campaign contributions from Leslie Wexner, described in the spot as an associate of convicted sex offender Jeffrey Epstein. The advertisement stated that Husted had received more than $100,000 from Wexner and noted that more than $120 million in total advertising across the cycle referenced Epstein. Husted’s campaign responded that Brown had also accepted donations from Wexner’s wife in prior cycles. Brown won the Senate race.

House Democratic advertisement on domestic-abuse allegations

The House Majority PAC, a Democratic super PAC, tested multiple advertisements for measurable effects on voter opinion. One advertisement that received the strongest internal testing results highlighted allegations made by the former wife of Republican Representative Max Miller of Ohio. The spot listed claims that included scalding with hot water and fracturing a child’s collarbone. Miller denied the allegations and stated that his former wife had mental-health challenges. Internal testing data shared by the PAC indicated a 15-point drop in Miller’s favorable rating and an approximately 10-point shift in the race. Multiple Republicans, including Senator Bernie Moreno of Ohio, whose daughter was Miller’s former wife, urged Miller to withdraw. Miller lost the election.

Advertisement responding to attacks on Michigan Senate nominee

Republican advertisements and statements, including comments from Trump, described Democratic Senate nominee Abdul El-Sayed of Michigan as a “jihadist” and raised questions about possible terrorist ties. The El-Sayed campaign responded with an advertisement that opened in black-and-white footage of an older woman asking where El-Sayed came from, then shifted to color as she and another older man identified themselves as his grandparents from Livingston County, Michigan. The advertisement received $1.8 million in spending, according to AdImpact data, beginning after the Democratic primary. El-Sayed won the Senate race.

French-language advertisement by Republican in Maine

Former Republican Governor Paul LePage of Maine, seeking to flip a Democratic House seat, produced an advertisement that addressed immigration policy while highlighting his personal background. The spot included LePage speaking in French, noting that French was his first language in Lewiston, and stated his support for legal immigration alongside opposition to illegal immigration. As of November 7, LePage remained one of the few Republicans positioned to gain a seat not altered by redistricting.

Texas Senate nominee contrasts record with opponent

Democratic nominee James Talarico in Texas released an advertisement that listed differences between his background and that of Republican Attorney General Ken Paxton. Talarico stated that he had never been indicted for fraud, reported to the FBI for bribery, or impeached by his own party. Talarico won the Senate race, becoming the first Democrat to do so in Texas since 1988.

Kansas Republican advertisement on past lawsuits

Republican Senator Roger Marshall of Kansas arranged for production of an advertisement defending his record as an obstetrician who had filed lawsuits against patients for unpaid debts. The advertisement was created without the knowledge of his senior campaign advisers. Marshall stated in the spot that he had never had anyone arrested. The New York Times had reported in September that Marshall had filed suits against more than 700 patients and that at least 81 individuals were arrested after missing court dates; others faced wage garnishment and an 18 percent interest rate on debts. The advertisement circulated after a local radio host posted it. Marshall lost to a Democratic challenger, marking the first Democratic Senate victory in Kansas in nearly a century.

Ohio Republican advertisement featuring opponent’s estranged mother

Republican nominee Vivek Ramaswamy for governor of Ohio released an advertisement in which the estranged mother of Democratic nominee Amy Acton described Acton as a liar and urged voters not to support her. Acton stated she had not spoken to her mother since age 12, following charges against her stepfather. Republican Governor Mike DeWine called the advertisement “deeply, deeply troubling.” Other Republicans, including Trump and Vice President JD Vance, defended its use. Ramaswamy lost the race.

North Carolina Senate advertisement that prompted response

The Senate Leadership Fund, a Republican super PAC, aired an advertisement featuring Ronald Hayes, whose son had been murdered, attributing crime trends in North Carolina to Democratic nominee and former Governor Roy Cooper. Hayes later told news outlets that he had been misled about the advertisement’s purpose and held no objection to Cooper. Cooper’s campaign produced a response advertisement highlighting Hayes’s statements and spent nearly $3 million on the reply, according to AdImpact. Republican strategist Carter Wrenn stated that the response advertisement affected Whatley’s credibility. Cooper won by a wide margin.

Maine Republican advertisement on candidate qualifications

Republican Senator Susan Collins of Maine aired an advertisement in which former broadcaster Bill Green stated that the Senate race was not equivalent to “buying a cord of wood” and referred to Democratic nominee Troy Jackson’s work as a logger. Democrats described the remark as conveying condescension. Jackson used the line to draw attention to heating-oil prices, which had risen amid the war in Iran; roughly half of Maine homes rely on fuel oil. Jackson appeared in public dressed as a cord of wood on Halloween. Republican strategist Lance Dutson said the advertisement left an impression that Collins was out of touch. Jackson defeated Collins.

This selection of advertisements illustrates a range of strategies and outcomes observed during the cycle. Additional advertisements from both parties addressed issues such as the economy, immigration and candidate records, with varying levels of spending and measured impact.

Investigation Log · 18 steps

Starting investigation...

Investigating The New York Times

Searching for "The New York Times bias rating AllSides Media Bias Fact Check Ad Fontes"

Verify NYT's established bias rating from neutral evaluators.

Framing

Described Republican attacks on Abdul El-Sayed as "Islamophobic attacks" and "suggest[ing] he had ties to terrorists" without providing evidence or context for the claims, while presenting the Democratic counter-ad positively.

This applies a moral label ("Islamophobic") as established fact rather than reporting the specific statements and letting readers evaluate, creating an impression that Republican criticism was baseless bigotry.

Cherry-Picking

Selected 10 ads where 7-8 examples highlight Democratic effectiveness or Republican failures/backfires, in an election framed as Democratic landslide.

The curation emphasizes one party's success, potentially omitting Republican effective ads that don't fit the narrative.

Emotional Manipulation

Used loaded phrasing like "brutal" for a Democratic ad on domestic abuse allegations and "explosive spot" for Ramaswamy's controversial ad, while noting Republican backlash.

Emotional language amplifies the impact of Democratic ads and frames Republican ones as ugly or troubling.

Writing analysis narrative

Analysis narrative ready

Narrative analysis generated

Writing verdict summary

Writing neutral rewrite

Investigation complete. Preparing report...

Curates mostly Democratic-success examples and applies loaded terms like 'Islamophobic' without evidence to portray one side's ads as effective and the other's as cringe.

Neutral rewrite ready

Neutral rewrite generated

**Investigation complete.** The NYT piece uses curated selection of ads (mostly Democratic wins or Republican missteps) plus loaded framing ("Islamophobic attacks") to reinforce a Democratic-landslide narrative. Propaganda grade: **C**. Main device: Curated Selection. Archetype: Coastal progressive media observer. Report submitted.

The Compass

You see how this outlet sees the world.

How do you see it? Find your political shape in a few minutes.

Take the test

Or check your own article