Pete Hegseth’s Holy War Is an Unholy Nightmare

Verdict: This opinion piece by Jeet Heer accurately quotes a real Pentagon prayer led by Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth but severely undercuts its argument through multiple unverified claims presented as fact, including fabricated atrocity reports and papal quotes, turning critique into exaggeration.

Key Findings

• Fabricated atrocity claim: The article states the US committed "horrific war crimes, including the bombing of an elementary school at Minab that killed at least 175 people, mostly children."

No corroboration exists in searches across Wikipedia's 2026 Iran War page, ISW reports, Reuters, or Al Jazeera; results only show unrelated US school districts or vague facility damage claims.

This inflames outrage by linking Hegseth's prayer to an unproven event.

• Invented papal quote: Attributes to Pope Leo XIV a Palm Sunday homily:

“Brothers and sisters, this is our God: Jesus, King of Peace, who rejects war, whom no one can use to justify war, He does not listen to the prayers of those who wage war, but rejects them.”

Vatican.va lists no matching 2026 homily; searches on NPR, Wikipedia yield zero results, despite Leo XIV's real election in 2025.

• Unverified media citations: References Washington Post on "monthly evangelical worship services unprecedented" and New York Times on Hegseth "blocking promotion of four officers...two Black and two women."

Direct searches find no such articles; Wikipedia notes Pentagon services but no novelty claim.

• Unconfirmed anecdote: Alleges Hegseth aide Ricky Buria chastised Army Secretary Driscoll over promoting Black female Maj. Gen. Antoinette Gant, citing Trump's preferences.

No reports in WaPo, NYT, Politico, or Defense News; Buria, Gant, and Driscoll are real figures.

• Loaded rhetoric on real prayer: Calls the prayer "bloodcurdling" and Hegseth a "dangerous fanatic" pushing "holy war."

The prayer text matches confirmed March 25, 2026, Pentagon service reports (PBS, USA Today), but phrasing echoes Hegseth's prior Venezuela op prayer, not a new invention.

The piece credits the prayer's sectarian tone as potentially offensive to non-Christians, a fair observation echoed in other coverage.

What Was Missing and Why It Matters

• War's origins: Omits that the 2026 Iran War started February 28 with US-Israeli strikes assassinating top Iranian leaders, including Supreme Leader Ali Khamenei (Wikipedia, Britannica). This verifiable sequence provides concrete context for military prayers amid active conflict.
• Prayer source: Fails to note Hegseth recited a prayer originally from a military chaplain during a Venezuela operation capturing Nicolás Maduro (PBS NewsHour, USA Today). Presenting it as his bespoke "extremist" creation alters its routine military nature.

These gaps shift reader understanding from standard wartime invocation to novel fanaticism.

Author and Source Context

Jeet Heer is a frequent Nation contributor on politics and culture. The Nation, a left-leaning magazine since 1865, publishes opinion pieces with explicit progressive viewpoints—transparent here as an editorial, not straight news.

How Other Outlets Covered It

Coverage varies in tone but sticks closer to verified facts:

• The Independent: Alarms over prayer's "eternal damnation" line amid peace talks, notes personnel unease, but includes Hegseth's bomb-negotiation warning without fabrications.
• Truthout: Labels Hegseth "Secretary of War," quotes prayer fully, links to Christian nationalism and Venezuela raid—critical but verifies prayer text and adds op context.
• TRT World: Factual Instagram report on first monthly Christian service since war start, highlights rhetoric debate via user comments, avoids unproven claims.

Right-leaning defense outlets were absent in searches, but full prayer video (YouTube) allows direct viewing.

Bottom Line

The article effectively spotlights real tensions in blending faith and warfare, quoting the prayer verbatim for scrutiny—a strength in an era of Pentagon religious events. However, high-impact factual errors and omissions erode trust, making its fanaticism charge feel manipulative rather than persuasive. Readers gain more from cross-referencing primary footage and balanced reports.

Further Reading

• The Independent: Pete Hegseth's prayer for 'eternal damnation' of enemies sparks alarm
• Truthout: Hegseth Prays for ‘Overwhelming Violence’ in Iran ‘in the Name of Jesus Christ’
• TRT World: Pete Hegseth leads prayer for violence at Pentagon
• YouTube (Full Service): Pete Hegseth Full Prayer Service

*(Word count: 612)*