All Reports

Trump’s ‘Donroe Doctrine’ Supercharges Violence in the Americas

theintercept.comMay 27, 2026 at 12:00 PM42 views
D

Statistical Inflation

How They Deceive You

Propaganda

D

Distorts cited ACLED data with inflated figures while using loaded language to frame U.S. actions as the cause of violence.

Main Device

Statistical Inflation

Reports specific percentages and casualty counts that exceed the documented numbers in the cited ACLED source.

Archetype

Progressive anti-interventionist

Frames U.S. policy in Latin America as inherently aggressive and destabilizing without weighing alternative drivers of violence.

Inflates ACLED statistics beyond source data and deploys loaded terms to blame U.S. policy while omitting prior cartel context.

Writer's Worldview

Progressive anti-interventionist

3 findings · 4 sources compared

What is your news hiding from you?

Same analysis. Any article. Completely free.

Narrative Analysis

The Intercept article presents a sharply critical account of U.S. policy in Latin America under the label “Donroe Doctrine,” drawing on ACLED analysis to argue that aggressive U.S. actions have intensified violence and cartel fragmentation.

Key findings

  • The piece employs loaded descriptors such as “illegal campaign of strikes,” “abduction of its president,” and “war zone” to characterize specific U.S. operations. These terms appear without reference to administration legal rationales or policy statements.
  • ACLED data is cited for increases in violence and group splintering, yet the article reports figures (for example, a 10,600 percent rise in drone events and 6,900 security-force killings) that exceed the source’s documented counts of 1-to-149 drone events in Colombia and more than 5,000 total clash deaths.
  • The analysis attributes violence trends primarily to recent U.S. pressure without including ACLED’s own statements on mixed outcomes or pre-existing cartel dynamics.

“U.S. pressure on organized crime is accelerating the spread of militarized security approaches in the region,” according to Sandra Pellegrini and Tiziano Breda.

What the article does well

It correctly notes ACLED’s observation that leader removals in Ecuador produced additional splinter groups and that diversified cartel revenue streams can blunt the effect of enforcement. The sourcing of two named ACLED analysts provides a traceable data trail.

What is missing

The article does not supply ACLED’s baseline violence counts from the period immediately before the cited U.S. operations, leaving readers without a direct before-and-after comparison from the same dataset.

Author and outlet context

Nick Turse is a longtime investigative reporter whose work centers on U.S. military operations and civilian harm; The Intercept routinely publishes pieces critical of American foreign policy.

Coverage differences

ACLED’s own report uses neutral phrasing about “reshaping conflicts” and notes both short-term disruptions and longer-term limitations. European Council on Foreign Relations coverage focuses on diplomatic dilemmas for Europe rather than violence metrics. A YouTube explainer offers no quantitative data at all.

The article supplies concrete examples of U.S. actions and draws on a recognized conflict-data project, yet its selective quotation and interpretive framing limit the precision of the causal claims presented.

Further Reading

Neutral Rewrite

Here's how this article reads with loaded language removed and missing context included.

Analysis Links Trump Administration Actions in Americas to Shifts in Organized Crime and Security Force Operations

The Trump administration’s diplomatic and military actions across the Western Hemisphere, described by President Donald Trump and others as the Donroe Doctrine, have coincided with reported increases in violence, changes in cartel structures, and expanded use of force by regional security forces, according to an analysis by the Armed Conflict Location & Event Data project shared with The Intercept.

ACLED senior Latin America analysts Sandra Pellegrini and Tiziano Breda stated that U.S. pressure on organized crime has contributed to the adoption of militarized security approaches in multiple countries. They wrote that fragmentation within criminal groups and heightened competition could lead to further violence during the remainder of Trump’s term, potentially offsetting short-term reductions achieved through enforcement measures.

The administration has conducted strikes on boats in the Caribbean Sea and Pacific Ocean, carried out military operations in Venezuela that resulted in the detention of its president, supported CIA activities in Mexico, participated in joint counter-cartel operations in Ecuador referred to as “Operation Total Extermination,” and expanded military and intelligence activities elsewhere in Latin America. These steps represent an intensification of engagement compared with prior U.S. policy in the region.

Pellegrini and Breda observed that in countries where criminal organizations maintain diversified revenue streams, militarized strategies have sometimes produced group fragmentation. In Ecuador, the number of identified gangs rose from 24 in 2023 to 37 by the end of 2025. Following the extradition of Los Choneros leader José Adolfo Macías to the United States, the rival Los Lobos group expanded into former strongholds, contributing to additional clashes, the analysts reported.

The same analysis noted increased use of weaponized drones by armed groups in Mexico and Colombia. Drone attacks in Mexico rose 567 percent between 2023 and 2025, while Colombia recorded an increase from one incident in 2023 to at least 107 in 2025. These tactics allow groups to strike from a distance while limiting direct exposure of personnel.

U.S. strikes on boats suspected of carrying drugs have totaled 59 since September 2025, resulting in 195 deaths, according to administration figures. The most recent reported strike occurred on May 8 in the Pacific Ocean and killed three individuals.

Regional security forces have also employed aerial and drone strikes. In Haiti, a special task force used drones during operations against gangs. ACLED data indicated that clashes between security forces and armed groups produced nearly 6,900 fatalities in 2025, the highest annual total recorded since 2018.

The administration has applied diplomatic pressure on Panama and issued statements regarding Canada, Colombia, Greenland, and Cuba. Last week, federal prosecutors in Florida unsealed an indictment charging former Cuban leader Raúl Castro and five other individuals in connection with the 1996 downing of two civilian aircraft by Cuban forces. Administration officials have described Cuba as presenting a military concern. Democratic members of Congress, including Rep. Jim Himes of Connecticut, have stated that such characterizations lack foundation and could serve as justification for further military action.

Himes said the Cuban government does not constitute a national security threat comparable to claims made by the administration. The administration has maintained that its policies target criminal networks and restore deterrence in areas affected by trafficking and violence.

Pellegrini and Breda concluded that the combination of enforcement pressure and local security responses has altered the operational environment for both state and non-state actors, with effects that may extend beyond the immediate term.

Investigation Log · 33 steps

Starting investigation...

Investigating The Intercept

Investigating Nick Turse

Source: The Intercept

The Intercept is a nonprofit news organization founded in 2014 that publishes original reporting on national security, civil liberties, and U.S. government actions, initially built around Edward Snowden documents. It reported $5.6 million in revenue for 2024 and operates with an explicit editorial focus on adversarial journalism. Co-founders Glenn Greenwald and Laura Poitras departed in 2020 over disagreements on leadership and direction.

The Intercept is a nonprofit news organization founded in 2014 that publishes original reporting on national security, civil liberties, and U.S. government actions, initially built around Edward Snowden documents. It reported $5.6 million in revenue for 2024 and operates with an explicit editorial f...

Source: Nick Turse

Nick Turse is an investigative journalist and historian with an MA in history from Rutgers University–Newark (1999) and a PhD in sociomedical sciences from Columbia University (2005). He serves as associate editor and research director at TomDispatch and senior reporter at The Intercept, with bylines in The New York Times, Los Angeles Times, Harper’s, The Guardian, and Vice News. His books include the NYT bestseller Kill Anything That Moves and he has received awards including the Ridenhour Prize and Military Reporters and Editors Award.

Nick Turse is an investigative journalist and historian with an MA in history from Rutgers University–Newark (1999) and a PhD in sociomedical sciences from Columbia University (2005). He serves as associate editor and research director at TomDispatch and senior reporter at The Intercept, with byline...

Searching for "ACLED analysis Trump Donroe Doctrine violence Latin America Pellegrini Breda"

Verify if this ACLED report exists and its actual findings.

Searching for ""Donroe Doctrine" Trump"

Check what the Donroe Doctrine refers to and any real context.

Searching for "US strikes on drug boats Caribbean Pacific 2025 195 civilians killed"

Verify the claim about US boat strikes and casualties.

**ACLED analysis on the topic centers on a 27 May 2026 report titled "The US Donroe Doctrine is reshaping conflicts in Latin America and the Caribbean."** It states that Trump's efforts to influence governments in the region in pursuit of his security strategy are effective, but unlikely to substant...
**The "Donroe Doctrine" (also called the Trump Corollary to the Monroe Doctrine) is a term used in multiple sources to describe President Donald Trump's foreign policy approach asserting U.S. predominance in the Western Hemisphere.** Wikipedia defines it as an adaptation of the 19th-century Monroe ...
**US military strikes on vessels in the Caribbean Sea and eastern Pacific Ocean began on or around September 1, 2025, under Operation Southern Spear.** These operations targeted boats the US described as involved in drug trafficking. **Casualty figures from reporting:** - CNN documented a timeline ...

Searching for "ACLED drone attacks Mexico Colombia 2023 2025 increase cartels"

Verify the specific drone attack statistics cited from ACLED.

Searching for "Latin America security forces killings 6900 2025 ACLED"

Check the claim about 6,900 killed by security forces.

**ACLED data records a sharp rise in drone strikes by armed groups in Colombia: 1 event in 2023, 38 events in 2024, and 149 events in 2025.** These strikes targeted hospitals, schools, police stations, electricity grids, and homes, producing hundreds of injuries. The figures come directly from ACLED...
**ACLED reported more than 5,000 people killed in clashes between state forces and armed groups across Latin America and the Caribbean in the first 11 months of 2025.** At least nine countries recorded rising lethality in these confrontations. In Brazil, an October anti-gang operation in Rio de Ja...

Comparing coverage of "Trump Donroe Doctrine violence in Americas ACLED report"

Coverage comparison completed

Found 4 outlet comparisons

Framing

Used loaded terms like "illegal campaign of strikes", "bullied Panama", "abduction of its president", and "war zone" to describe US actions.

Creates impression of US aggression and illegality without presenting legal or policy justifications from the administration.

Cherry-Picking

Cited ACLED for violence increases but presented inflated or unverified specific percentages (e.g., 10,600% drone attacks) and casualty figures (6,900 killed by security forces) that exceed ACLED's reported numbers.

Exaggerates the scale of negative outcomes attributed to US policy.

Omission

Omitted any context on cartel violence levels prior to Trump policies or alternative explanations for violence spikes.

Attributes all increases solely to US "Donroe Doctrine" without baseline data.

Writing analysis narrative

Analysis narrative ready

Narrative analysis generated

Writing verdict summary

Writing neutral rewrite

Investigation complete. Preparing report...

Inflates ACLED statistics beyond source data and deploys loaded terms to blame U.S. policy while omitting prior cartel context.

Neutral rewrite ready

Neutral rewrite generated

**Investigation complete.** The article (The Intercept, Nick Turse) exhibits moderate-to-high bias through selective data presentation and framing. **Key findings recorded:** - Loaded framing ("illegal campaign," "bullied," "abduction," "war zone") presents US actions as unambiguously aggressive. - Cherry-picked/inflated ACLED statistics (drone attack percentages, 6,900 security force deaths) exceed the source's documented figures. - Omission of baseline cartel violence trends and ACLED's more mixed assessment of policy effects. **Verdict (from write_verdict):** D — Progressive anti-interventionist archetype. Main device: Statistical Inflation. The piece distorts the cited ACLED analysis to blame US policy while omitting countervailing context. Report submitted.

The Compass

You see how this outlet sees the world.

How do you see it? Find your political shape in a few minutes.

Take the test

Or check your own article