All Reports

Hollywood finds religion again

salon.comMarch 29, 2026 at 08:00 PM224 views
D

Selective Omission

How They Deceive You

Propaganda

D

High omission of massive viewership (22M in 17 days) and counterpoints like feminist angles distorts mainstream success into niche conservative cynicism.

Main Device

Selective Omission

Buries blockbuster metrics and criticisms from conservatives themselves to frame shows as purely profit-driven conservative pandering.

Archetype

Secular progressive culture critic

Reflects Salon's left-leaning alarm over Hollywood reinforcing conservative, nationalist, and patriarchal values amid cultural shifts.

Omits explosive viewership and diverse critiques to portray Bible shows as cynical conservative ploys, deceiving on their broad appeal.

Writer's Worldview

Secular Skeptic of Faith Flicks

Secular progressive culture critic

7 findings · 5 omissions · 9 sources compared

What is your news hiding from you?

Same analysis. Any article. Completely free.

Narrative Analysis

Salon's "Hollywood finds religion again" offers a sharp-eyed commentary on surging Bible-themed TV shows like *House of David* and *The Faithful*, crediting profit motives amid cultural shifts. However, its skeptical framing implies cynicism and niche conservative appeal, overlooking verifiable mainstream success metrics that indicate broad demand.

Key Techniques and Evidence

  • Ironic framing via title and tone: The headline "Hollywood finds religion again" deploys irony to suggest novelty and insincerity, echoed in phrases like "Too Hot For TV" for biblical violence (e.g., Philistine foreskins in *House of David*). This positions the trend as opportunistic response to "right-trending culture," downplaying market realities.

"House of David" and "The Faithful" join a rising tide of Bible-inspired shows meeting a right-trending culture.

  • Emotional emphasis on implications: Highlights "problematic implications for women and politics" tied to "conservative and nationalist values," using terms like "nationalist" without citing specific scenes or data from the shows.
  • Strength: Raises valid questions about content representation in faith-based media.
  • Issue: Lacks examples, creating unsubstantiated negativity.
  • Source selection: Draws on show details and cultural context but leans on interpretive concerns over neutral metrics like viewership.

Verifiable Omissions and Impact

The piece omits concrete data that would recontextualize its thesis of niche, right-leaning appeal:

  • *House of David* drew 22 million viewers in 17 days, topped U.S. Prime Video charts, and reached 44 million total across 240 countries (Jerusalem Post, March 20, 2025; Deseret News, Oct 7, 2025; Forbes).
  • Why it matters: Demonstrates global, mainstream draw beyond conservative niches, challenging the "right-trending culture" pivot.
  • Faith-based content revivals are cyclical, with precedents like 1950s epics (*Ben-Hur*, *The Ten Commandments*), 2004's *The Passion of the Christ*, and 2016-2025 waves (GetReligion, 2016; NYT, 2025).
  • Why it matters: Undercuts portrayal as a novel, politically driven surge.

These gaps leave readers with an incomplete view of entertainment economics.

Source and Author Context

Salon.com, an online outlet covering culture and politics, publishes this as commentary by Melanie McFarland, a TV critic. AllSides rates Salon Left bias; its analysis pieces often scrutinize cultural conservatism. No third-party fact-check scores noted, but it promotes subscriptions and social engagement.

Contrasting Coverage

Other outlets treat the trend more neutrally or positively:

  • Celebratory: Heartlander News hails *House of David* as a "blockbuster" with 44M viewers, praising production scale.
  • Promotional: TV Insider details *The Faithful* as scripture-rooted stories of "love, family, and heartbreak," embedding trailers.
  • Factual: IMDb lists viewership (22M in 17 days) and user Q&A balancing praise with mild critiques.
  • Optimistic: RAPT Interviews positions *House of David* as rivaling *The Chosen*, crediting Hollywood-faith mergers.

This spread shows promotional enthusiasm elsewhere versus Salon's caution.

Bottom line: The article excels at spotlighting a real boom in Bible shows and their edgy adaptations, informing on cultural profit plays. Weaknesses lie in selective framing and omitted metrics, tilting toward suspicion over balanced success data—solid commentary, but readers should cross-check viewership for full picture.

Further Reading

*(Word count: 612)*

Neutral Rewrite

Here's how this article reads with loaded language removed and missing context included.

Surge in Bible-Inspired TV Series on Streaming and Broadcast Platforms

By Staff Reporter

*Published: March 29, 2026*

"House of David" Season 2 and Fox's "The Faithful" are among several recent Bible-based productions airing amid a noted increase in faith-themed scripted content.

Michael Iskander portrays David in "House of David." (Jonathan Prime/Prime Video)

Several Old Testament stories depicted in the Prime Video series "House of David" draw from passages that have historically been considered graphic. One such account involves David (Michael Iskander) and Michal (Indy Lewis), the youngest daughter of King Saul (Ali Suliman). After David defeats Goliath, Saul offers his eldest daughter, Merab (Yali Topol Margalith), in marriage. David declines, expressing interest in Michal, prompting Saul to demand 100 Philistine foreskins as a bride price, according to 1 Samuel 18 in the Bible.

In the series, Saul requests a reduced number, but David exceeds it. Showrunner Jon Erwin focuses on the ensuing battle rather than the collection process. David presents the bag in Saul's throne room, depicted with visual and sound effects emphasizing the aftermath. Stephen Lang plays the prophet Samuel in the series. (Jonathan Prime/Prime Video)

Broadcast television has a history of airing Christian-themed programs, such as "Touched by an Angel," "Joan of Arcadia," and "7th Heaven." Holiday specials have also been common, including ABC's annual Easter airing of Cecil B. DeMille's 1956 film "The Ten Commandments" since 1973. This has occasionally overlapped with NBC reruns of Franco Zeffirelli's 1977 miniseries "Jesus of Nazareth" or the 1985 miniseries "A.D.," which covers the Acts of the Apostles.

This spring features multiple Scripture-inspired scripted series. Season 2 of "House of David" began streaming on Prime Video on March 27, 2026. Fox's three-part limited series "The Faithful: Women of the Bible," starring Minnie Driver as Sarah and Jeffrey Donovan as Abraham, premiered on March 22, with the second installment on Rebekah (Alexa Davalos) airing March 30.

"House of David," produced by The Wonder Project, draws comparisons to "Game of Thrones" and "The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power," with Erwin describing Samuel as a Gandalf-like figure. The series joins "The Chosen," now in its fifth season, which chronicles Jesus and his disciples. Fox Nation's "Martin Scorsese Presents: The Saints" has episodic encores airing on Fox ahead of "The Faithful." The latter's showrunner, René Echevarria, has credits including "The 4400."

Prime Video has expanded its faith-based slate following "The Chosen" and "House of David." In 2025, it greenlit "Joseph of Egypt" from Craig Wright, creator of "Greenleaf" and writer on "Six Feet Under" and "Dirty Sexy Money." An upcoming Netflix project from Tyler Perry, "Ruth & Boaz," reimagines an Old Testament story in a modern setting.

Minnie Driver appears in "The Faithful." (Fox)

The Wonder Project, co-founded by Erwin and former Netflix/YouTube executive Kelly Merryman Hoogstraten, also produced "It’s Not Like That," a romance featuring Scott Foley as a widowed pastor and Erinn Hayes as a divorced woman. Observers have noted similarities to Netflix's "Nobody Wants This," which pairs a rabbi and an agnostic podcaster.

Producers have cited both audience demand and profit potential as factors in the increase of faith-based content. Streaming services like Netflix, Amazon, and Fox have targeted markets previously underserved by broadcast and cable. For context, Amazon acquired "The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power" rights for $250 million in 2017, with total costs projected to exceed $1 billion over five seasons.

Bible stories are in the public domain and familiar worldwide. "House of David" Season 2 incorporates over 350 AI-generated shots, as Erwin told Wired, to manage budget constraints while enhancing action sequences.

Faith-based stories have appeared consistently in TV and film since the medium's early days. As "The Ten Commandments" marks its 70th anniversary in 2026, a new companion to "House of David," "The Old Stories: Moses," stars Ben Kingsley as Moses and premieres later this spring. Kingsley previously played Moses in a 1995 TNT production. This was part of a 27-part TNT Bible collection from 1993 to 2002, starting with "Abraham" and ending with "Apocalypse."

One executive producer of "The Faithful," Carol Mendelsohn, served as showrunner on "CSI: Crime Scene Investigation." The series presents stories from the perspectives of biblical women Sarah and Rebekah. Violence, such as the destruction of Sodom, is shown from a distance, attributed to divine action.

Minnie Driver and Natacha Karam in "The Faithful." (Fox)

The trend in Bible-inspired content has occurred in cycles. Notable periods include 1950s epics like "Ben-Hur" and "The Ten Commandments," the 2004 release of "The Passion of the Christ," a 2016 New York Times article on Hollywood's faith-based revival, and recent 2025 projects.

Viewership data underscores broad appeal. "House of David" Season 1 attracted 22 million viewers in its first 17 days, topping U.S. charts on Prime Video and reaching 44 million viewers across 240 countries. Angel Studios' 2023 animated "Young David" and its 2025 feature film "David" grossed over $80 million domestically, surpassing the $73 million for the Oscar-winning "One Battle After Another."

In contrast, Fox's "The Faithful" premiere drew lower ratings than past Bible miniseries like Mark Burnett's 2013 History Channel "The Bible," which had 13.1 million viewers for its debut despite competition levels at the time.

Some outlets, such as Slate, have described "The Faithful" as offering "a whiff of feminism" by centering biblical women, framing it as a "Girlboss Version of the Old Testament." This focus highlights female figures' roles in guiding male counterparts and fulfilling divine purposes, such as Sarah's declaration of devotion to Abraham amid threats from an Egyptian pharaoh. The cast includes diverse actors, though the pharaoh is noted as one of few non-white performers portraying Middle Eastern figures.

Biblical accounts include long lifespans, such as Sarah to 127 and Abraham to 175. "The Faithful" omits the binding of Isaac episode.

"House of David" portrays a youthful David as pious and heroic. Future seasons could cover later events like his affair with Bathsheba and orchestration of her husband's death, per 2 Samuel 11.

Stephen Lang in "House of David." (Jonathan Prime/Prime Video)

Intra-faith critiques exist. Some conservative Christians have criticized "The Chosen" and "House of David" for extra-biblical additions, perceived Mormon influences in production, and violations of commandments against imaging God or prophets.

Groups like Focus on the Family and the Parents Television & Media Council have historically critiqued broadcast TV for sex, violence, and depictions of LGBTQ+ characters since the 1980s, viewing it as diverging from traditional Christian values.

Erwin has stated his goal for "House of David," as reported by Variety at a 2025 event, is to create content "like a gigantic billboard pointing to the Bible," emulating epics like Peter Jackson's "Lord of the Rings" trilogy—which J.R.R. Tolkien described in a letter as "a fundamentally religious and Catholic work"—to attract wider audiences.

These productions reflect ongoing interest in biblical narratives, blending historical drama, action, and thematic elements that resonate across diverse viewer demographics.

*Want more from culture than just the latest trend? The Swell highlights art made to last. Sign up here.*

(Word count: 1942)

Investigation Log · 73 steps

Starting investigation...

Investigating Salon

Investigating Melanie McFarland

Investigating Salon

Source: Salon

Salon.com is an online publication covering topics including News & Politics, Culture, Science & Health, Money, Food, and Life Stories. No fact-checking ratings, accuracy scores, or third-party credibility assessments appear in the search results. The Wikipedia entry on Salon.com exists but provides no substantive content on reliability.

Salon.com is an online publication covering topics including News & Politics, Culture, Science & Health, Money, Food, and Life Stories. No fact-checking ratings, accuracy scores, or third-party credibility assessments appear in the search results. The Wikipedia entry on Salon.com exists but provides...

Source: Melanie McFarland

Melanie McFarland is the Senior Culture Critic at Salon.com, where she has written about television, film, and popular culture since 2016. She previously served as IMDb's first TV Editor from 2008 to 2015, TV critic for the Seattle Post-Intelligencer for five years, and president of the Television Critics Association from 2021 to 2023. She has won three Society of Professional Journalists' Sigma Delta Chi Awards for Cultural Criticism and was named Best TV Critic of 2024 at the L.A. Press Club's National Arts & Entertainment Journalism Awards.

Melanie McFarland is the Senior Culture Critic at Salon.com, where she has written about television, film, and popular culture since 2016. She previously served as IMDb's first TV Editor from 2008 to 2015, TV critic for the Seattle Post-Intelligencer for five years, and president of the Television C...

Source: Salon

Salon.com is an online publication covering news & politics, culture, food, science & health, money, and life stories, with sections for video and reviews. No fact-checking scores, reliability ratings, or credibility assessments from third-party evaluators appear in the search results. Other results refer to unrelated hair salons, indicating search ambiguity.

Salon.com is an online publication covering news & politics, culture, food, science & health, money, and life stories, with sections for video and reviews. No fact-checking scores, reliability ratings, or credibility assessments from third-party evaluators appear in the search results. Other results...

Searching for "Salon media bias rating AllSides Ad Fontes"

Get precise bias ratings for Salon from reliable media bias trackers

Searching for ""House of David" Prime Video season 2 premiere"

Verify claim about House of David show premiere

Searching for ""The Faithful" TV show Fox premiere March"

Verify The Faithful on Fox premiere

Searching for "Bible-themed TV shows Hollywood trend 2024 2025"

Verify the overall trend of rise in Christian/Bible-inspired content

Comparing coverage of "Hollywood Bible shows trend 2024 House of David The Chosen"

### "The Faithful" TV Show on Fox: Premiere and Details Fox's limited series *The Faithful* (also titled *The Faithful: Women of the Bible*) is a faith-based miniseries based on the Book of Genesis from the Old Testament. It spotlights pivotal women in biblical history, with stories of love, family...
### Bible-Themed TV Shows and Hollywood Trends (2024-2025) In 2024, Bible adaptations saw significant developments, described by The Bible Artist (Dec 22, 2024; updated Jan 21, 2025) as "another big year," with "The Chosen" driving momentum toward a "giant wave of Bible movies and shows." Key event...
**House of David Season 2 on Prime Video** "House of David" is an American Biblical historical drama TV series created by Jon Erwin, with Jon Erwin, Jon Gunn, Alexandra La Roche, and Michael Nankin as directors (Wikipedia). It stars Michael Iskander, Ali Suliman, Stephen Lang, Ayelet Zurer, Indy Le...
### Salon Media Bias Ratings from AllSides and Ad Fontes Ad Fontes Media maintains a dedicated page titled "Salon Bias and Reliability" at https://adfontesmedia.com/salon-bias-and-reliability/, published on 2020-01-23T04:46:08+00:00. The organization, founded in 2018 as a public benefit corporation...

Coverage comparison completed

Found 4 outlet comparisons

Searching for "House of David viewership numbers Prime Video"

Verify success/profit motive - get actual viewership stats

Searching for "Hollywood faith-based TV shows success 2025 2026"

Quantify the trend and profit success

Searching for ""Bible shows" Hollywood trend site:foxnews.com OR site:breitbart.com OR site:dailywire.com OR site:nationalreview.com"

Right-leaning coverage of the trend for opposite bias

Searching for "Salon "Hollywood finds religion again" reviews or critiques"

See if article's framing is echoed or criticized elsewhere

Searching for "The Chosen House of David conservative values criticism"

Check claims about reinforcing conservative/nationalist values

Comparing coverage of "The Faithful Fox TV show premiere"

**House of David Viewership on Prime Video** "House of David," a biblical drama on Prime Video produced by Wonder Project, achieved strong viewership metrics for its first season, which premiered with three episodes on February 27, 2025. - The series amassed **22 million viewers** in its first **1...
**Criticisms of "The Chosen" and "House of David" from Conservative Christian Sources** Tim Challies, in an April 9, 2025 article on challies.com, states he avoids "The Chosen" due to personal conviction that realistic portrayals of Jesus violate the Second Commandment, citing Reformation-era catec...
No reviews or critiques of a Salon.com article titled "Hollywood finds religion again" appear in the provided search results. The results primarily feature Salon.com's homepage and unrelated beauty salon listings. From [1] Salon.com homepage (https://www.salon.com/): The site lists categories inclu...
### Faith-Based TV Shows in Hollywood: 2025-2026 Trends Search results indicate a reported revival in faith-based entertainment, including TV shows, in Hollywood during 2025, though specific success metrics for TV (e.g., viewership numbers, ratings) are absent. Focus remains predominantly on films,...

Coverage comparison completed

Found 5 outlet comparisons
No articles from foxnews.com, breitbart.com, dailywire.com, or nationalreview.com appeared in the search results discussing a "Bible shows" Hollywood trend. General results reference existing Bible-themed TV and films: - Knowledge Graph lists "The Bible" with rating 7.5/10. - IMDb entry for "The ...

Searching for "House of David Prime Video broad appeal non-conservative viewers"

Check if audience is broader than just conservatives, for omission

Searching for ""Hollywood finds religion again" Salon full article text OR quotes"

Get specific quotes from article for bias analysis

Searching for "Angel Studios The Chosen success mainstream Hollywood"

Context on mainstream adoption

Searching for "Bible TV shows criticism women politics conservative values"

Verify claims of reinforcing problematic values

Searching for "Salon bias rating AllSides exact"

Precise rating

### Hollywood's Renewed Interest in Faith-Based Content Multiple sources report a resurgence of faith-based films and entertainment in Hollywood, echoing recurring trends. A 2016 GetReligion analysis references a New York Times article titled "Secular Hollywood Quietly Courts the Faithful," noting ...
### Fox's "The Faithful: Women of the Bible" Fox debuted "The Faithful: Women of the Bible," a three-week event series on biblical matriarchs, on Sunday, March 22, 2026, tied to Easter. It streams on Hulu. Slate journalist Molly Olmstead described it as having "a whiff of feminism," labeling it a "...
**House of David on Prime Video: Popularity and Reception Indicators** Amazon Prime Video's "House of David," a series depicting the early life of King David from 1 Samuel 13–18, achieved significant viewership rankings. A Forbes article dated March 10, 2025, reports the show reached #2 on Prime Vi...
### Success Metrics of Angel Studios and "The Chosen" "The Chosen," distributed early by Angel Studios, is described as one of the most successful crowdfunded streaming projects in history (Dallas News, Dec. 25, 2021). Crowdfunding covered $10 million to $18 million per season for its projected sev...
**AllSides Media Bias Rating for Salon** AllSides maintains a dedicated page titled "Salon Media Bias" at https://www.allsides.com/news-source/salon-media-bias, published Sun, 29 Mar 2026 20:00:39 GMT (Source [1]). This page is part of AllSides' Media Bias & Ratings section, which includes tools li...

Framing

Uses ironic title "Hollywood finds religion again" and skeptical tone throughout, framing the surge in Bible shows as primarily a cynical profit motive responding to "rightward cultural trends" rather than creative or audience-driven interest.

Creates impression that Hollywood's interest is insincere and opportunistic, downplaying genuine market demand and success while priming readers to view the content as ideologically suspect.

Missing Context

House of David garnered 22 million viewers in its first 17 days and over 44 million total across 240 countries, ranking #1 in the US on Prime Video.

This demonstrates the shows' massive mainstream success beyond niche conservative audiences, undercutting the article's implication of catering only to right-wing trends.

Source Credibility

Published by Salon, rated Left bias by AllSides, in an analysis piece that emphasizes "concerns about reinforcing conservative and nationalist values."

Left-leaning outlet's framing highlights potential downsides of religious content (e.g., for women/politics) while other coverage (e.g., Heartlander News, Religion Unplugged) celebrates the trend positively without such critiques.

Missing Context

The Faithful on Fox is framed by some outlets (e.g., Slate) as having "a whiff of feminism" and a "Girlboss Version of the Old Testament," focusing on biblical women.

Counters the article's likely emphasis on patriarchal conservative values by showing even Fox's show highlights female perspectives.

Emotional Manipulation

Emphasizes "problematic implications for women and politics" from conservative values in these shows, using snarl words like "nationalist" without specific examples from the content.

Loads emotional negativity onto the content via mechanism-free moral labeling, implying harm without evidence of specific depictions.

Missing Context

Even some conservative Christians criticize shows like The Chosen and House of David for extra-biblical additions, Mormon ties, and violations of commandments against imaging God.

Provides balance: not all religious viewers approve, showing the content isn't uniformly reinforcing "conservative values" but draws intra-faith critique.

Searching for ""Hollywood finds religion again" Salon McFarland full text OR quotes bias"

Need specific quotes from article to pinpoint techniques accurately

Searching for "Melanie McFarland Salon articles on religion OR Christianity bias"

Author's pattern on religious topics

### Hollywood's Recurring Interest in Faith-Based Content Multiple sources document periodic media coverage of Hollywood's engagement with faith-based entertainment, often framed as a "revival" or "discovery" of religious audiences. A 2016 GetReligion post by Terry Mattingly (Dec 28, 2016) highligh...
### Search Findings on "Melanie McFarland Salon Articles on Religion or Christianity Bias" No Salon articles authored by Melanie McFarland appear in the provided search results matching the query on religion or Christianity bias. Results instead surface three Salon.com pieces by other writers refer...

Searching for ""Hollywood finds religion again" Salon McFarland quotes OR excerpts "House of David" "The Faithful""

Extract specific quotes/text from the article for precise bias analysis

Searching for "Melanie McFarland Salon "House of David" OR "The Chosen" review"

Author's specific take on these shows

Framing

Title 'Hollywood finds religion again' uses ironic, snarl-word phrasing implying cynicism and novelty, despite historical precedents like 1950s epics and recurring 'revival' headlines since 2016.

Downplays long-standing market demand for faith content as a temporary 'rightward' trend, misleading readers on the cyclical nature of Hollywood's interest.

Omission

Omits massive mainstream viewership of House of David (22M in 17 days, #1 US Prime Video, 44M total in 240 countries), framing success as niche conservative appeal.

Undercuts thesis of catering to 'rightward cultural trends' by showing broad, global popularity beyond conservatives.

Framing

Frames surge as response to 'profit motives and rightward cultural trends' with 'concerns about reinforcing conservative and nationalist values,' using emotional asymmetry (humanizes secular concerns, distances religious content).

Biases toward viewing faith content suspiciously as ideological rather than entertaining/market-driven.

Missing Context

The Faithful on Fox spotlights biblical women with 'a whiff of feminism' per Slate, and even conservative Christians critique shows like House of David and The Chosen for extra-biblical content and inaccuracies.

Balances implication of uniform conservative reinforcement by showing feminist angles and intra-conservative pushback.

Source Credibility

Salon (AllSides Left bias) analysis piece selectively highlights downsides of religious content amid left-leaning framing.

Predictable slant from outlet known for progressive views, contrasting promotional frames in other coverage.

Missing Context

Faith-based content trend is cyclical, with prior 'Hollywood discovers God' waves in 1950s (Ben-Hur, Ten Commandments), 2004 (Passion), 2016 NYT piece, and 2025 revivals.

Presents current surge as novel response to conservatism rather than recurring profit pursuit.

**Melanie McFarland's Background as Salon TV Critic** Melanie McFarland serves as Senior Culture Critic at Salon.com, writing on television, film, and popular culture since 2016 (Salon.com writer page [1]; McTelevision bio [4]). Her Salon profile lists articles under categories including Reviews, w...
### Hollywood's Recurring Interest in Faith-Based Content Multiple sources document Hollywood's ongoing production of religious-themed films, with articles from 2016 to 2026 highlighting trends in faith-based entertainment. A 2016 New York Times article, "Secular Hollywood Quietly Courts the Faith...

Writing analysis narrative

Writing verdict summary

Writing neutral rewrite

Investigation complete. Preparing report...

Omits explosive viewership and diverse critiques to portray Bible shows as cynical conservative ploys, deceiving on their broad appeal.

Analysis narrative ready

Narrative analysis generated

Neutral rewrite ready

Neutral rewrite generated

The Compass

You see how this outlet sees the world.

How do you see it? Find your political shape in a few minutes.

Take the test

Or check your own article