All Reports

Don't want a data center in your town? You might be a Chinese spy.

motherjones.comMay 23, 2026 at 12:00 PM142 views
C

Selective Omission

How They Deceive You

Propaganda

C

Notable spin via one-sided framing that elevates local concerns while dismissing national security arguments without evidence or counterbalance.

Main Device

Selective Omission

Ignores documented Chinese influence and IP issues in tech, treating the espionage claim solely as a rhetorical smear.

Archetype

Localist skeptic of national security pretexts

Prioritizes community control and environmental framing over geopolitical competition concerns in infrastructure debates.

Uses asymmetric scrutiny and omission of China-related context to portray security concerns as baseless smears rather than engaging the arguments.

Writer's Worldview

“Localist skeptic of national security pretexts”

3 findings

What is your news hiding from you?

Same analysis. Any article. Completely free.

Narrative Analysis

The Mother Jones article provides a clear window into local opposition against the proposed Utah data center but structures its reporting to emphasize the accusation as an unsubstantiated personal attack while allocating far less space to the project's stated national security and infrastructure rationale.

Key Findings

  • Selective framing of the core claim: The piece opens with O'Leary's Fox News appearance and immediately pairs it with denials from the named individuals, stating that O'Leary "has as yet not done so" regarding proof. It then devotes multiple paragraphs to quotes from Finlayson, Morgan, and Huntchings describing the accusation as motivated by project opposition and noting their modest compensation. This approach creates an early impression of the claim as rhetorical escalation rather than a substantive allegation requiring further examination.
  • Extensive sourcing on local impacts: The article quotes residents, ranchers, and environmental groups at length on projected emissions increases of up to 50 percent and concerns over land use. These details are presented with specific local context, including references to Utah's "libertarian streak" and bipartisan pushback. In contrast, the counter-position receives one sentence referencing O'Leary's "out-compute China" argument and a brief mention of a Trump executive order.
  • Limited scrutiny of project scale: Proponent claims about AI compute capacity and economic development appear only in passing. The text does not include data on projected job numbers, tax revenue, or comparisons to other large-scale data center approvals elsewhere in the United States.

What Was Missing

The article contains no references to publicly reported instances of foreign influence operations targeting U.S. infrastructure siting decisions or documented cases of intellectual property concerns in the AI sector between 2023 and 2025. These are concrete topics covered in congressional testimony and federal indictments during that period; their absence leaves readers without baseline information on why data center locations have drawn national security attention in multiple states.

Source and Author Context

Nathan Halverson is a senior reporter and producer at the Center for Investigative Reporting (Reveal). His prior work includes the 2024 documentary *The Grab*, which examined global competition for agricultural and water resources, and reporting that contributed to a $155 million financial settlement. His byline has appeared across NPR, CNN, PBS, and Fox News.

Bottom Line

The article succeeds at documenting concrete local objections and the personal impact of the accusation on the individuals named. At the same time, its narrow focus on the accusation as a dispute tactic and its limited inclusion of the project's broader strategic arguments produce an account that is more one-sided than the available public record on data center development would support.

Further Reading

No additional coverage comparisons were available in the source material for this analysis.

Neutral Rewrite

Here's how this article reads with loaded language removed and missing context included.

Kevin O’Leary Accuses Utah Critics of Data Center Project of Chinese Government Links

Utah political consultant Gabi Finlayson was driving out of a canyon last week when she learned she had been accused of acting as a Chinese government operative.

Finlayson and colleague Jackie Morgan were traveling to a speaking engagement in central Utah. When their vehicle regained cell service, multiple text messages alerted them to a video clip from a Fox News appearance by investor Kevin O’Leary. O’Leary, who is developing a proposed 40,000-acre data center campus in the state through his firm Stratos, stated that his team had examined IP addresses and identified “two cells inside of Utah” connected to the Chinese Communist Party. He named Finlayson and Morgan’s firm, Elevate Strategies, and the nonprofit Alliance for a Better Utah.

Finlayson and Morgan described the statements as false and said they stem from their public opposition to the project. Elizabeth Hutchings of Alliance for a Better Utah told Fox News she would likely receive higher compensation if foreign payments were involved. The two women said their objections rest on concerns that the project was advanced with limited prior public notice and could affect local resources. One University of Utah professor has estimated the facilities could raise the state’s net greenhouse gas emissions by as much as 50 percent if fully built.

O’Leary has framed the data center as necessary for U.S. technological capacity. In the same appearance he asked which adversary would seek to limit American electrical grid expansion and AI compute infrastructure, answering that only China fits the description. He indicated additional evidence would be released later. His investment firm has not responded to repeated requests for comment or documentation.

The exchange occurs against a backdrop of federal policy. A 2025 executive order signed by President Donald Trump directed agencies to accelerate permitting for data centers, citing the need to maintain U.S. leadership in artificial intelligence. The order states that achieving “unquestioned and unchallenged global technological dominance” constitutes a national security imperative. Trump has also held investments in companies supplying data center infrastructure.

Proponents of large-scale data centers argue the facilities support training and operation of advanced AI models, generate construction and operations employment, and contribute to local tax bases. Critics in Utah have pointed to electricity and water demands, particularly in arid regions, and to the scale of the proposed Stratos campus, described by opponents as the largest such project under consideration in the country.

Finlayson and Morgan work on Democratic campaigns in a state with Republican legislative majorities and publish a Substack covering state politics. They stated that opposition has drawn participants from varied political backgrounds, including ranchers and farmers concerned about rural infrastructure. Hundreds attended a Box Elder County commission meeting where the project received local approval earlier this month, and thousands submitted comments on associated water rights applications. A local group is exploring a referendum effort.

Utah’s legislature announced this week that it will examine the project’s potential effects on the Great Salt Lake, which has experienced declining water levels. Governor Spencer Cox, a Republican, stated that the initial rollout of the Stratos proposal “was not good.” Additional protests are planned at the state capitol over Memorial Day weekend.

O’Leary’s accusation has not been accompanied by public evidence linking the named individuals or groups to foreign governments. Finlayson said the volume of local opposition reflects genuine resident concerns rather than external direction.

Data center development has drawn scrutiny in multiple western states over resource use and siting processes. At the same time, federal and industry statements have linked expanded domestic compute capacity to competition in artificial intelligence, where Chinese firms have pursued parallel advances. Public records show multiple U.S. government actions addressing technology transfer risks, including indictments and export controls related to semiconductor and AI research, though no connection has been established in this specific Utah dispute.

The Military Installation Development Authority, a state entity, has already approved aspects of the project, which may limit the practical effect of any county-level reversal. Construction timelines and final configuration remain subject to further regulatory steps and potential litigation.

Finlayson characterized the broader reaction as residents asserting input over large infrastructure decisions. O’Leary has maintained that external actors are the primary source of resistance. Both positions continue to circulate without independent corroboration of the foreign-agent claim.

Investigation Log · 28 steps

Starting investigation...

Investigating Mother Jones

Investigating Nate Halverson

Searching for "Kevin O'Leary Utah data center Chinese spy accusation"

Verify the core claim about O'Leary accusing activists of being Chinese operatives.

**Kevin O'Leary accused specific Utah critics of his Box Elder County data center project of ties to China during a Fox Business segment.** He named Gabi Finlayson and Jackie Morgan, cofounders of Elevate Strategies, stating: "These are proxies for the Chinese government is my argument, and if they'...

Source: Mother Jones

Mother Jones is a nonprofit magazine founded in 1976 that publishes investigative journalism on politics, environment, and culture. It operated under the Foundation for National Progress (a 501(c)(3)) until a 2024 merger with The Center for Investigative Reporting, its current publisher. Clara Jeffery is editor-in-chief and Monika Bauerlein has been CEO since 2015.

Mother Jones is a nonprofit magazine founded in 1976 that publishes investigative journalism on politics, environment, and culture. It operated under the Foundation for National Progress (a 501(c)(3)) until a 2024 merger with The Center for Investigative Reporting, its current publisher. Clara Jeffe...

Source: Nate Halverson

Nathan Halverson is a senior reporter and producer at the Center for Investigative Reporting (Reveal) in San Francisco and a two-time Emmy winner. He served as lead reporter and producer on the 2024 documentary The Grab, which was nominated for four Emmys and streams on Hulu. His reporting has appeared on NPR, CNN, Fox News, PBS NewsHour, and Mother Jones, with international work and investigations into financial fraud that contributed to a $155-million settlement.

Nathan Halverson is a senior reporter and producer at the Center for Investigative Reporting (Reveal) in San Francisco and a two-time Emmy winner. He served as lead reporter and producer on the 2024 documentary The Grab, which was nominated for four Emmys and streams on Hulu. His reporting has appea...

Searching for "Utah Stratos data center greenhouse gas emissions 50 percent University of Utah"

Verify the emissions claim attributed to a professor.

Searching for ""Stratos" data center Utah size "largest" OR "40,000-acre""

Confirm project scale and if it's the largest proposed.

Searching for "Trump 2025 executive order data centers national security"

Verify the executive order reference.

**On July 23, 2025, President Trump signed Executive Order 14318, "Accelerating Federal Permitting of Data Center Infrastructure."** The order directs federal agencies to expedite permitting and environmental reviews for data centers and supporting infrastructure, including high-voltage transmissio...
**The Stratos data center project in Box Elder County, Utah, is a proposed 40,000-acre AI facility backed by investor Kevin O’Leary and advanced through the Utah Military Installation Development Authority.** Multiple sources reference an estimate that full buildout would increase Utah’s greenhouse ...
**No relevant findings on a "Stratos" data center in Utah.** The search results returned five unrelated projects using the name "Stratos" or "StratOS": - thestratos.org describes an AI platform. - stratos-linux.org is the site for StratOS Linux distributions. - stratos.ai offers an AI-powered comm...

Framing

The article leads with O'Leary's accusation and frames it as a baseless smear motivated by opposition to the project, while presenting critics' environmental and local control concerns at length without equivalent scrutiny of national security or AI competition arguments.

Creates impression that O'Leary's position is extreme and evidence-free, while downplaying legitimate geopolitical context around data centers and AI infrastructure.

Omission

Omits any discussion of documented Chinese efforts to influence US infrastructure debates or IP theft in tech/AI sectors, treating the "China spy" framing solely as a rhetorical tactic.

Leaves readers without context on why data center opponents might legitimately raise foreign adversary concerns in 2025-2026 AI race.

Cherry-Picking

Emphasizes local bipartisan backlash and "libertarian streak" in Utah while omitting scale of project benefits claimed by proponents (AI compute capacity, economic development).

Presents opposition as near-universal without balancing the national security/economic case made by O'Leary and Trump EO.

Writing analysis narrative

Writing verdict summary

Writing neutral rewrite

Investigation complete. Preparing report...

Uses asymmetric scrutiny and omission of China-related context to portray security concerns as baseless smears rather than engaging the arguments.

Analysis narrative ready

Narrative analysis generated

Neutral rewrite ready

Neutral rewrite generated

**Investigation complete.** Mother Jones (progressive-leaning nonprofit with environmental focus) and reporter Nate Halverson produced a piece that accurately reports O’Leary’s unsubstantiated accusations and local backlash but systematically frames the story to portray national-security arguments as cynical smears. **Verified claims:** - O’Leary did accuse specific Utah activists (Elevate Strategies, Alliance for a Better Utah) of Chinese ties on Fox Business, citing IP addresses, and promised (but has not released) proof. - The 50% GHG increase estimate from a University of Utah professor is widely cited in Utah coverage. - Trump’s July 2025 EO on expedited data-center permitting exists and explicitly references national security and AI infrastructure. **Bias findings recorded:** - Framing that presents O’Leary’s position as extreme while giving extensive, sympathetic space to opponents’ environmental and “imposed on us” arguments. - Omission of any context on documented Chinese IP theft, influence operations, or the scale of the US-China AI compute race. - Cherry-picking that emphasizes near-universal local anger without balancing the economic/AI-dominance case made by proponents. **Verdict:** C (moderate bias). Main device is selective omission of geopolitical context. Archetype: localist skepticism of national-security pretexts. A neutral rewrite would add the missing national-security and AI-competition arguments alongside the local concerns, note the lack of evidence for both the espionage claim and the strongest emissions projections, and avoid treating one side’s framing as common sense. Report submitted.

The Compass

You see how this outlet sees the world.

How do you see it? Find your political shape in a few minutes.

Take the test

Or check your own article