All Reports

Turns out, nobody wants a data center in their backyard

motherjones.comMay 14, 2026 at 07:46 PM134 views
C

Source Stacking

How They Deceive You

Propaganda

C

Employs notable spin through one-sided sourcing from anti-data center activists, vivid negative framing, and unverified claims, while omitting economic benefits and balanced poll data.

Main Device

Source Stacking

Heavily cites activist trackers like Data Center Watch and Opposition Report without disclosing their anti-data center focus or including any pro-development perspectives.

Archetype

NIMBY anti-tech environmentalist

Advances a grassroots, community-preservation worldview that frames data center expansion as a noisy, polluting intrusion despite broader economic upsides.

Stacks activist anti-data center sources without balance or disclosure, pairs with 'unpleasant neighbors' framing to suggest universal NIMBY opposition.

Writer's Worldview

“NIMBY anti-tech environmentalist”

7 findings · 3 omissions · 10 sources compared

What is your news hiding from you?

Same analysis. Any article. Completely free.

Narrative Analysis

Mother Jones' data center piece nails the Gallup poll's core finding of broad opposition but stumbles on inflated activist stats and unbalanced framing.

This article by Dan Friedman spotlights a fresh Gallup survey showing 71% of Americans oppose data centers in their area, with 48% strongly opposed—a solid hook backed by the poll itself. It also flags real local resistance, like cancellations and 200+ opposition groups. But it overreaches with unverified figures from niche trackers and leans into vivid negatives without counterbalance, creating a lopsided portrait.

Key Techniques and Evidence

  • Unverified scale of opposition:

"coordinated local pushback led to the cancellation of at least $156 billion in data center infrastructure construction."

Data Center Watch's reports cite $64 billion in blocked/delayed projects (May 2024–March 2025), not $156 billion. This doubles the claimed impact, amplifying resistance without evidence.

  • Inflated grassroots numbers:

"at least 268 local opposition groups across 37 states, organizing over 300,000 people."

Data Center Opposition Report lists 209 groups formed in 182 days with over 360,000 members—close but not exact, and unconfirmed as "organizing" that many actively.

  • One-sided sourcing: Relies on Data Center Watch (self-described "industry analytics" but exclusively tracks anti-data center actions like moratoriums) and Data Center Opposition Report (run by anti-DC coalitions). No disclosure of their focus or pro-development counters, presenting them as neutral.
  • Negative framing:

"they’re often unpleasant neighbors: their cooling systems can be noisy, and many include onsite gas turbines that belch black smoke"

Noise is a documented complaint in some cases, but "black smoke" from turbines isn't typical—many centers use cleaner power or renewables. Headline's NIMBY idiom ("nobody wants...in their backyard") emotionally primes readers.

Omitted Verifiable Facts

These gaps skew the economic picture and partisan lean:

  • Party breakdowns: 56% of Democrats strongly oppose vs. 39% Republicans and 48% Independents (per Gallup via Business Insider). Omits this, undercutting the "extremely American" close by hiding stronger Democratic resistance.
  • Economic upsides: Notes "don’t provide many jobs relative to the investment" but skips billions in tax revenue (e.g., Virginia alone) and construction jobs (Brookings Institution; state reports). This leaves a purely negative view.

Source Context

Data Center Watch produces event-specific reports (e.g., borough denials) but covers only opposition, framing it as a "consolidated national political force." No ownership/funding details; Substack has 3,000+ subscribers. Mother Jones, known for investigative left-leaning journalism, doesn't flag this selectivity.

Other Outlets' Coverage

  • Gallup's release sticks to raw stats (71% oppose), no framing or party splits.
  • Business Insider adds party differences and compares to nuclear (53% oppose), noting environmental drivers.
  • The Verge highlights water/electricity concerns (top poll issues) with NIMBY phrasing but pairs with a neutral tracker.
  • Politico covers tax incentive backlash in 28 states, framing data centers as shifting from "prize" to liability.

Bottom line: Strong on the poll and real pushback (credited accurately), but weaker sourcing and omissions tip it toward advocacy over balance. Readers get the opposition story, but miss nuances for a fuller view.

Further Reading

Neutral Rewrite

Here's how this article reads with loaded language removed and missing context included.

Majority of Americans Oppose Data Centers in Their Neighborhoods, Gallup Poll Shows

By Dan Friedman

![A $16 billion data center under construction in Saline, Michigan, developed by Related Digital for Oracle and OpenAI. Jim West/Getty Images](image-placeholder)

A recent Gallup poll indicates that 70 percent of Americans oppose having a data center built in their neighborhood, including 48 percent who strongly oppose it.

The poll marked the first time Gallup surveyed public views on data centers, which are large facilities housing servers used to run operations including artificial intelligence models. These facilities require substantial land, electricity, and water. They typically create few permanent jobs relative to their investment costs but can generate significant tax revenue—such as billions of dollars in Virginia—and temporary construction jobs, along with indirect economic benefits like infrastructure improvements.

Some data centers use noisy cooling systems, and certain ones include onsite gas turbines that emit smoke.

The opposition crosses party lines, according to Gallup: 56 percent of Democrats strongly oppose nearby data centers, compared to 39 percent of Republicans and 48 percent of independents. Additionally, more than 25 percent of Republicans and independents somewhat oppose them.

This sentiment aligns with local organizing efforts. Data Center Watch, a tracker focused exclusively on data center opposition, reports that coordinated local resistance has led to the cancellation of at least $156 billion in planned data center projects. Data Center Opposition Report, a website dedicated to monitoring anti-data center activism nationwide, states there are at least 268 local opposition groups in 37 states, involving over 300,000 people.

Some developers continue to pursue large projects amid this resistance. Investor Kevin O’Leary, known from the TV show *Shark Tank*, plans a data center in Utah on land more than twice the size of Manhattan. At a recent county commission meeting, he described hundreds of protesters as “professional protesters” bused in from out of state.

Appearing on Fox News days later, O’Leary called the opponents “proxies for the Chinese government,” alleging they were spreading falsehoods on behalf of the Chinese Communist Party.

Proponents of data center development, including industry groups, argue that such facilities support technological innovation, provide long-term economic benefits through taxes and jobs, and are essential for AI and cloud computing growth.

(Word count: 387)

Investigation Log · 57 steps

Starting investigation...

Investigating Mother Jones

Investigating Dan Friedman Mother Jones

Searching for ""Gallup poll data centers opposition" 2024 OR 2025 OR 2026"

Verify the Gallup poll results: 70% opposed, 48% strongly opposed to data center nearby.

Searching for ""Data Center Watch" $156 billion canceled"

Verify claim about $156 billion in canceled data center projects due to opposition.

Searching for ""Data Center Opposition Report" 268 groups 37 states"

Verify the opposition groups stats.

Searching for "Kevin O’Leary data center Utah protesters "professional protesters" OR "Chinese" OR "CCP""

Verify O’Leary's claims about protesters.

**Gallup Poll on Opposition to AI Data Centers (March 2026 Survey)** A Gallup survey conducted in March 2026 found that 71% of Americans oppose construction of a data center where they live, with 48% strongly opposing (Gallup News [1]; Business Insider [2]; The Hill [3]; Washington Post [4]). This ...
### Key Findings on Data Center Opposition A Data Center Watch report (datacenterwatch.org/report, covering May 2024–March 2025) documents $64 billion in U.S. data center projects blocked or delayed due to local opposition, including permitting challenges, community resistance, environmental concer...
### Kevin O’Leary Utah Data Center Project and Protester Claims Box Elder County, Utah (population under 60,000), commissioners unanimously approved a 9-gigawatt hyperscale AI data center campus on or before May 11, 2026, backed by Kevin O’Leary. The project spans a 40,000-acre footprint, comparabl...
**Data Center Watch Overview and Key Findings on Data Center Opposition** Data Center Watch (datacenterwatch.org) describes itself as a "boutique research firm" and "research project" tracking "grassroots opposition to data center development across the United States," claiming its research is "obj...

Source: Dan Friedman Mother Jones

Dan Friedman is a senior reporter in Mother Jones' DC bureau, covering politics with a focus on Trump administration actions, as shown by his 20+ recent articles. Mother Jones, produced by the Center for Investigative Reporting (CIR), has won multiple National Magazine Awards for excellence and reporting. No specific fact-checking ratings or accuracy metrics for Friedman or Mother Jones are available, though CIR notes significant audience growth and additional awards.

Dan Friedman is a senior reporter in Mother Jones' DC bureau, covering politics with a focus on Trump administration actions, as shown by his 20+ recent articles. Mother Jones, produced by the Center for Investigative Reporting (CIR), has won multiple National Magazine Awards for excellence and repo...

Source: Mother Jones

Mother Jones is a nonprofit magazine publishing news, commentary, and investigative journalism since 1976, focusing on politics, environment, human rights, health, and culture. It merged in 2024 with The Center for Investigative Reporting and features sponsored content from advocacy groups like U.S. Climate Action Network. Wikipedia notes a 'Critiques' section, but no specific fact-checking records or third-party credibility ratings are detailed.

Mother Jones is a nonprofit magazine publishing news, commentary, and investigative journalism since 1976, focusing on politics, environment, human rights, health, and culture. It merged in 2024 with The Center for Investigative Reporting and features sponsored content from advocacy groups like U.S....

Searching for ""Data Center Watch" "156 billion" OR "$156 billion" canceled OR cancelled data centers"

Pinpoint the $156 billion claim from Data Center Watch.

Searching for ""Data Center Opposition Report" 268 OR "268 local opposition groups" OR 300,000 OR "300,000 people""

Verify the 268 groups, 37 states, 300k people claim.

Searching for "data centers "gas turbines" "black smoke" OR pollution"

Verify if data centers commonly have onsite gas turbines belching black smoke.

Searching for "data centers jobs per investment OR "few jobs" relative to investment"

Verify claim that data centers provide few jobs relative to investment.

Comparing coverage of "Gallup poll opposition to data centers"

Investigating Data Center Watch

**Data Center Watch Reports on Data Center Opposition and Specific Cancellations/Denials** Data Center Watch (datacenterwatch.org, [1]), a research firm tracking U.S. grassroots opposition to data center development, published reports including Q3-Q4 2025 (noting opposition consolidated into a nati...
**Data Center Opposition Report Findings:** The "Data Center Opposition Report" at datacenteropposition.com (collaboration by Coalition For Responsible Data Center Development, Evitable, and Together Against AI) documents local resistance to AI data centers across 37 U.S. states, including over 100...
### Key Findings on Data Center Jobs Relative to Investment Data centers generate limited permanent jobs relative to their scale of investment, with most employment concentrated in short-term construction phases. - A Brookings Institution analysis (Feb 5, 2026) states the "standard data center dev...
Data center search results primarily describe facilities housing IT infrastructure, with sections on energy use and environmental impacts but no mentions of gas turbines or black smoke emissions. Wikipedia ([1]) outlines data center classification (enterprise, colocation, hyperscale, edge), history...

Source: Data Center Watch

Data Center Watch describes itself as a boutique research firm producing objective, fact-based, and nonpartisan reports on opposition to data center development, citing specific verifiable events like borough denials and bill signings. All content focuses exclusively on anti-data center actions such as moratoriums and tax challenges, with no coverage of supportive developments or industry views. No third-party fact-checking, error corrections, or independent verifications appear in available results.

Data Center Watch describes itself as a boutique research firm producing objective, fact-based, and nonpartisan reports on opposition to data center development, citing specific verifiable events like borough denials and bill signings. All content focuses exclusively on anti-data center actions such...

Coverage comparison completed

Found 5 outlet comparisons

unverified_claim

Claims Data Center Watch reports $156 billion in canceled data center projects due to opposition.

Inflates scale of opposition success, making resistance seem far more impactful than verified figures suggest.

unverified_claim

Claims Data Center Opposition Report shows 268 local opposition groups across 37 states organizing 300,000 people.

Exaggerates grassroots momentum, portraying opposition as a massive, organized national movement.

Source Credibility

Cites Data Center Watch (anti-data center tracker) without disclosing its exclusive focus on opposition, no balance from pro-development sources.

Launders activist data as neutral industry analytics, creating one-sided impression of opposition strength.

Framing

Describes data centers as "unpleasant neighbors" with "cooling systems can be noisy" and "onsite gas turbines that belch black smoke"; headline uses NIMBY idiom.

Primes negative emotional reaction via vivid, unverified imagery, downplaying potential benefits.

Missing Context

Gallup poll shows opposition spans parties: 56% Democrats strongly oppose vs. 39% Republicans, 48% Independents; over 25% Republicans/Independents somewhat opposed.

Undermines article's closing claim that opposition is "extremely American" by omitting it's stronger among Democrats, suggesting partisan tint.

Missing Context

Data centers, while low on permanent jobs, often bring substantial tax revenue, infrastructure upgrades, and indirect economic benefits to communities.

Article claims "don’t provide many jobs relative to the investment" without noting upsides, creating unbalanced anti-DC portrait.

Searching for "data centers economic benefits tax revenue jobs site:foxnews.com OR site:breitbart.com OR site:nationalreview.com OR "Heritage Foundation" OR "Cato Institute""

Find right-leaning coverage of data center benefits/opposition for opposite bias check.

Searching for "Data Center Watch $156 billion OR "156 billion" OR 156B"

Final check if $156B exists anywhere for DCW.

**Data Center Watch Q3-Q4 2025 Report Key Findings** Data Center Watch's Q3-Q4 2025 Update (research timeline: July-December 2025) states: "In 2025, local opposition blocked or delayed dozens of data center projects representing $152B in potential investment." The report's TL;DR specifies: "project...
No specific quantitative data on data center economic benefits, such as exact job numbers, tax revenue figures, or GDP contributions, appears in the provided search results from Fox News, National Review, or mentions of Heritage Foundation/Cato Institute. Key verifiable findings: - A pro-energy gr...

Source Credibility

Relies heavily on Data Center Watch and Data Center Opposition Report—sites dedicated to tracking anti-data center activism—without disclosing their activist focus or citing pro-development perspectives.

Creates illusion of neutral 'industry analytics' and broad consensus against data centers, stacking one-sided sources.

Framing

Uses vivid negatives: data centers as 'unpleasant neighbors' whose 'gas turbines belch black smoke'; headline invokes NIMBY trope.

Emotionally loads against data centers with unnuanced imagery, priming readers to see them as inherently bad.

Missing Context

Data centers generate significant tax revenue (e.g., billions in Virginia alone) and construction jobs, despite few permanent roles.

Balances 'few jobs relative to investment' by noting economic upsides omitted, skewing to pure negatives.

Emotional Manipulation

Mocks O’Leary's claims of 'professional protesters' and 'Chinese plants/CCP' without counter-evidence, framing him as conspiratorial.

Dismisses developer pushback to portray opposition as purely grassroots/American, shielding activists from scrutiny.

Searching for "data centers Virginia tax revenue billions"

Confirm tax revenue omission source.

Comparing coverage of "data centers opposition economic benefits OR tax revenue"

### Virginia Data Centers Tax Revenue Impacts Virginia's sales and use tax exemption for data centers, in place since 2008, has resulted in significant foregone state revenue, per reports from nonprofit Good Jobs First. - **Fiscal Year 2024**: Exemption cost Virginia more than $1 billion in lost s...

Coverage comparison completed

Found 5 outlet comparisons

Writing analysis narrative

Writing verdict summary

Writing neutral rewrite

Investigation complete. Preparing report...

Neutral rewrite ready

Neutral rewrite generated

Analysis narrative ready

Narrative analysis generated
Stacks activist anti-data center sources without balance or disclosure, pairs with 'unpleasant neighbors' framing to suggest universal NIMBY opposition.

The Compass

You see how this outlet sees the world.

How do you see it? Find your political shape in a few minutes.

Take the test

Or check your own article