All Reports

Map shows how the price of gas in your state compares with the rest of the US

businessinsider.comMay 6, 2026 at 12:04 PM124 views
B

False Equivalence

How They Deceive You

Propaganda

B

Provides accurate AAA-sourced gas price data and interactive map but introduces minor framing issues by symmetrically portraying US-Iran blockades without context of US-initiated strikes.

Main Device

False Equivalence

Symmetrically attributes Strait of Hormuz blockades to 'US and Iran' without specifying Iran's response to prior US-Israel attacks, creating misleading balance.

Archetype

Mainstream Business Centrist

Poses as neutral data-driven reporting while subtly downplaying US responsibility in geopolitical conflicts affecting markets.

Informs via accurate state gas price map and data, but deceives by false equivalence in US-Iran blockade framing and omitting conflict initiation.

Writer's Worldview

Mainstream Business Centrist

4 findings · 1 omission · 4 sources compared

What is your news hiding from you?

Same analysis. Any article. Completely free.

Narrative Analysis

Verdict: This Business Insider piece delivers a useful interactive map with accurate AAA-sourced gas price data amid 2026's surge, but symmetric framing of US-Iran blockades and unverified expert quotes introduce subtle distortions in explaining the crisis.

Strengths in Data and Visualization

Business Insider excels here with timely, state-by-state comparisons via an interactive map, drawing from AAA data showing the national average rising from $2.98/gallon on February 27 to over $4 by March 31. California's jump above $6 is correctly noted, as are lower prices in states like Oklahoma and Kansas. This makes complex volatility scannable for readers.

  • Accurate attributions: Ties rises to refinery outages, seasonal blends, and Strait of Hormuz blockades—verifiable factors per EIA reports.
  • Visual focus: Prioritizes user engagement over dense text, a smart choice for a price-comparison story.

Key Techniques and Issues

The article uses symmetric framing for the blockades, stating they occurred "by the US and Iran" without sequence details.

"Analysts say several factors are driving the increase. Blockades by the US and Iran in the Strait of Hormuz"

  • Evidence of technique: Web searches (CNBC April 30, 2026; Reuters; Al Jazeera) confirm US/Israel strikes on Iranian targets February 28 initiated the conflict, prompting Iran's strait closure, followed by US naval blockades on Iranian ports. This sequencing clarifies the supply trigger but is absent, creating an impression of parallel actions.
  • Impact: Readers may infer mutual escalation without the documented US-first military action.

Two unverified claims from GasBuddy analyst Patrick De Haan add unconfirmed authority:

  • Forecast: National summer averages "$3.50 to $5.50 a gallon."
  • Quote: "This is capitalism. When you put your house on the market, you're not like 'Yay, I'm going to take the cheapest bid.'"

Evidence: De Haan is credible (20+ years; cited in WSJ, CNN), but GasBuddy's January 2026 outlook predicted a $2.97 annual average pre-crisis. No sources confirm this exact range or quote post-spike, though plausible amid disruptions.

Sourcing transparency gap: Relies on an internal map and AAA without direct links; Business Insider has faced criticism for clickbait headlines, though authors Randy Yeip and Ben Shimkus specialize in data viz.

Verifiable Omissions and Why They Matter

  • US/Israel strikes on February 28, 2026: Multiple outlets (CNBC, Reuters, Al Jazeera) report these as the conflict's start, leading to Hormuz closures. Omission removes concrete causal chain for oil volatility, despite US production leadership—altering how readers weigh domestic vs. global factors.

No other major factual gaps; interpretive balance (e.g., US exports) isn't required.

Source Context

Patrick De Haan: Senior GasBuddy petroleum analyst since 2009; provides EIA-based forecasts featured widely. No political biases noted; promotes GasBuddy tools commercially.

Authors: Data journalists at BI, focused on interactives.

Coverage Differences

Other outlets vary in emphasis:

  • Guardian: Alarmist on "Iran war" inflation ($4.23 national; Brent $114.60), ties to Trump prep; omits refinery details.
  • Reuters: Supply-focused ("Iran war disruption" + 150k bpd outages); no prices or forecasts.
  • Muskegon Chronicle: Local Michigan (+82¢ weekly); reader skepticism on US self-sufficiency.
  • Anadolu Agency: Global forecasts (up to $5/gallon); broader energy instability.

Bottom line: Strong on accessible data and visuals—credit where due for helping readers check local impacts. Weaknesses in blockade sequencing and quote verification slightly erode trust, especially for geopolitically driven prices. Solid consumer tool, but cross-check sources for full context.

Further Reading

*(Word count: 612)*

Investigation Log · 65 steps

Starting investigation...

Investigating Business Insider

Investigating Randy Yeip

Investigating Ben Shimkus

Investigating Patrick De Haan GasBuddy

Searching for "US average gas price February 27 2024 AAA"

Verify national average $2.98 on Feb 27

Searching for "US average gas price March 31 2024 AAA over $4"

Verify surge to over $4 by March 31

Searching for "California average gas price April 30 2024 $6"

Verify CA topped $6 on April 30

Searching for ""blockades by the US and Iran" Strait of Hormuz 2024"

Verify claim of blockades by US and Iran in Strait of Hormuz

Searching for "US largest oil producer 2024"

Confirm US leads global oil production

### US Naval Blockade of Iran and Strait of Hormuz (Reported 2026 Events) Pentagon officials estimated that a U.S. naval blockade imposed on Iran resulted in $4.8 billion in lost oil revenue for Iran (The Hill, citing Defense Department). The U.S. military initiated blocking of shipping traffic in...
### US Average Gas Price on March 31, 2024 per AAA Search results do not include a direct AAA daily national average for March 31, 2024. A Facebook post from WDEF News 12 (March 31) stated: "Average U.S. gas prices topped $4 per gallon on March 31 for the first time since 2022, according to AAA" ([...
**U.S. Leads Global Oil Production in 2024 with Record Output** The U.S. Energy Information Administration (EIA) reports that U.S. crude oil production reached a new monthly record in August 2024 (Source [1]: "U.S. crude oil production established a new record in August 2024"). EIA further states t...
**AAA National Average Gas Prices, Late February 2024** According to AAA's official February 2024 gas price updates (gasprices.aaa.com/2024/02/): - February 1, 2024: $3.15 per gallon (rose 5 cents from prior week, due to oil costs in upper $70s per barrel and seasonal increases). - February 8, 202...
### California Average Gas Price on April 30, 2024 No search results confirm California average regular gasoline prices reached $6 per gallon on April 30, 2024. Available data indicates lower prices that year. - AAA Fuel Prices data ([4]) lists California monthly averages for early 2024 at $4.482 ...

Source: Ben Shimkus

Ben Shimkus is a reporter for Business Insider's Business News desk, covering cars, transportation, retail, and jobs, with a Master's in Journalism from NYU in 2024. His work has appeared in outlets like Rolling Stone, The Verge, Automotive News, USA Today, Daily Mail, and The U.S. Sun, where he launched the site's first vehicle review section. No fact-checking ratings, retractions, or controversies are documented, though headlines in Daily Mail often use emotive language like 'gut punch' and 'heartbreak'.

Ben Shimkus is a reporter for Business Insider's Business News desk, covering cars, transportation, retail, and jobs, with a Master's in Journalism from NYU in 2024. His work has appeared in outlets like Rolling Stone, The Verge, Automotive News, USA Today, Daily Mail, and The U.S. Sun, where he lau...

Source: Business Insider

Business Insider, founded in 2007, is a New York City-based financial and business news website that publishes original reporting and aggregates content from other outlets. It has been criticized for using factually incorrect clickbait headlines to attract viewership and for granting sponsors editorial control over native advertising content. As of 2011, it maintained a liberal policy on anonymous sources and has been nominated for several awards.

Business Insider, founded in 2007, is a New York City-based financial and business news website that publishes original reporting and aggregates content from other outlets. It has been criticized for using factually incorrect clickbait headlines to attract viewership and for granting sponsors editor...

Source: Randy Yeip

Randy Yeip has nearly 20 years of experience in news graphics and data visualization, including nearly 20 years at The Wall Street Journal where he served the last seven as deputy graphics director, leading a team of data journalists, developers, and graphic designers. He is currently data visualization director at Business Insider, overseeing news graphics and interactive storytelling with a focus on data and politics. His work has received recognition from the Society for News Design, Online Journalism Awards, and Best American Infographics, and he holds bachelor’s and master’s degrees from Michigan State University.

Randy Yeip has nearly 20 years of experience in news graphics and data visualization, including nearly 20 years at The Wall Street Journal where he served the last seven as deputy graphics director, leading a team of data journalists, developers, and graphic designers. He is currently data visualiza...

Source: Patrick De Haan GasBuddy

Patrick De Haan serves as senior petroleum analyst at GasBuddy with 20 years of experience analyzing oil markets, starting in 2005 and joining GasBuddy in 2009. He provides data-driven commentary on fuel prices, citing sources like EIA weekly reports, and is featured in major outlets including Wall Street Journal, CNN, Bloomberg, and others. His forecasts, such as GasBuddy’s annual Fuel Outlook, are described on his site as 'known for accuracy,' though no independent verification of specific accuracy rates appears.

Patrick De Haan serves as senior petroleum analyst at GasBuddy with 20 years of experience analyzing oil markets, starting in 2005 and joining GasBuddy in 2009. He provides data-driven commentary on fuel prices, citing sources like EIA weekly reports, and is featured in major outlets including Wall ...

Searching for "AAA US national average gas price February 27 2026 $2.98"

Verify Feb 27 2026 national avg $2.98

Searching for "AAA US national average gas price March 31 2026 over $4"

Verify March 31 2026 over $4

Searching for "AAA California average gas price April 30 2026 $6"

Confirm CA $6 on April 30 2026

Searching for "Oklahoma Kansas lowest gas prices US spring 2026"

Verify lowest in OK and KS

Searching for "Midwest refinery outages Great Lakes 2026 gas prices"

Verify refinery outages

Searching for "US gas exports record levels 2026"

Verify record exports

Searching for "Strait of Hormuz blockades US Iran 2026 oil supply"

Context on blockades and 20% world oil

Searching for "GasBuddy Patrick De Haan summer 2026 gas price forecast $3.50 to $5.50"

Verify expert quote and prediction

### AAA US National Average Gas Price on March 31, 2026 On March 31, 2026, the AAA national average price for regular gasoline was $4.018 per gallon, exceeding $4. This figure is reported directly from the AAA Fuel Prices website, as cited in a Rigzone article published that day (7:15 AM EST). GasB...
### Midwest Refinery Outages Impacting Great Lakes Gas Prices in 2026 A power outage at BP's Whiting Refinery in Indiana on April 27, 2026, is driving gas price increases across Midwest and Great Lakes states, including Wisconsin, Michigan, and Indiana. This marks the second major disruption at the...
### AAA US National Average Gas Prices, Late February 2026 AAA reported the US national average price for regular gasoline as **$2.98 per gallon** on **February 26, 2026**, up more than 5 cents from the prior week, amid the start of summer-blend gasoline production (Source: [1] AAA Gas Prices, Febr...
### U.S. Natural Gas Exports Reaching Record Levels in 2026 According to the U.S. Energy Information Administration (EIA), U.S. natural gas exports are projected to grow nearly 30% by 2027, driven by ramping up of LNG facilities ([1] EIA, "U.S. natural gas exports to grow nearly 30% by 2027 as LNG ...
### US-Iran Standoff and Strait of Hormuz Blockade (2026) In April 2026, President Donald Trump announced a U.S. naval blockade of Iran via the Strait of Hormuz, stating it would remain until Iran agrees to a nuclear deal (CNBC, Apr 30, 2026). Trump claimed on Fox News that Iran's oil infrastructur...
### AAA California Average Gas Price on April 30, 2026 According to AAA data cited in a CNBC report published April 30, 2026, the average price for regular gasoline in California reached $6.01 per gallon on Thursday, April 30, 2026. This marked the first time prices hit $6 per gallon since October ...
### Lowest Gas Prices in Oklahoma and Kansas, US Spring 2026 In spring 2026 (March-May), Oklahoma and Kansas ranked among states with the lowest average gas prices nationally. - On March 18, 2026, SlashGear reported the U.S. states with the cheapest average gas prices in March 2026 as Kansas, Nort...
GasBuddy's 2026 Fuel Price Outlook, released January 6, 2026, forecasts the U.S. national average gasoline price at $2.97 per gallon for the year—the lowest since 2020 and down 13 cents from 2025's $3.102 average. This marks the fourth consecutive yearly decline. Patrick De Haan, GasBuddy's head of ...

Searching for ""Blockades by the US and Iran" Strait of Hormuz gas prices Business Insider"

Check if article's phrasing on blockades is accurate or unique

Searching for "Patrick De Haan GasBuddy "huge range" summer gasoline prices $3.50 $5.50 2026"

Verify exact De Haan quote on price range

Comparing coverage of "US gas prices rise spring 2026 Strait of Hormuz blockade refinery outages"

Searching for "cause of US Iran Strait of Hormuz blockade 2026"

Context on who initiated blockades/conflict

### Timeline and Cause of 2026 US Naval Blockade of Strait of Hormuz On February 28, 2026, the United States and Israel launched military attacks on Iran during negotiations over Iran's nuclear program, according to a YouTube analysis citing related events (source [5]). Iran responded with missile...
### US Blockades of Iran and Oil Flow Impacts Search results highlight discussions of US naval enforcement actions against Iran, particularly affecting oil shipments, with limited details on Iranian blockades, Strait of Hormuz specifics, gas prices, or Business Insider coverage. - **Just Security ...
**Patrick De Haan's Background and Role at GasBuddy** Patrick De Haan is a senior petroleum analyst at GasBuddy, with over 15 years of experience analyzing oil and refined products markets since 2005. He joined GasBuddy in 2009 and holds a degree in Business Economics from DePaul University. De Haa...

Coverage comparison completed

Found 4 outlet comparisons

Framing

Phrases blockades as occurring "by the US and Iran" in the Strait of Hormuz, presenting both parties symmetrically without specifying sequence or initiation: Iran closed the strait in response to US-Israel strikes on Feb 28, 2026, after which US imposed naval blockade on Iranian ports.

Creates impression of mutual responsibility for supply disruptions rather than sequential actions in a US-initiated conflict, potentially downplaying US agency in the geopolitical trigger for price spikes.

Missing Context

US and Israel launched military attacks on Iran on February 28, 2026, initiating the conflict that led to Strait of Hormuz disruptions.

Provides causal context for the blockades mentioned, explaining why supply concerns arose despite US oil production leadership; omission leaves readers without the sequence of events driving global oil volatility.

unverified_claim

Attributes to Patrick De Haan a forecast of national average summer gasoline prices ranging from $3.50 to $5.50 a gallon, and the exact quote "This is capitalism. When you put your house on the market, you're not like 'Yay, I'm going to take the cheapest bid.'"

Expert forecast and analogy lend authority to explanation of high prices despite US production; if unverified, undermines credibility of key causal analysis.

Source Credibility

Relies on Business Insider's interactive map and AAA data without linking raw sources; outlet has history of clickbait headlines and sponsor-influenced native ads.

Click-driven model may prioritize engaging visuals over full sourcing transparency, potentially affecting reader trust in state-by-state comparisons during volatile period.

Searching for "Fox News gas prices spring 2026 Strait of Hormuz"

Right-leaning coverage of gas prices and Hormuz in 2026

Searching for "Breitbart OR Daily Wire gas prices Iran blockade 2026"

Conservative outlets on gas prices and blockade context

Searching for "Wall Street Journal gas prices US Iran war 2026"

Center-right coverage for comparison

unverified_claim

Quotes Patrick De Haan on summer gas prices ranging $3.50-$5.50 nationally and analogy 'This is capitalism... cheapest bid' explaining exports despite US production.

Lends expert authority to price persistence explanation; unconfirmed specifics undermine that.

### WSJ Reports on U.S. Gas Prices Amid 2026 Iran War According to Wall Street Journal coverage, U.S. gasoline prices rose 23.5% since the Iran war began, reaching a national average of $3.68 per gallon on Saturday (WSJ live coverage: "U.S. Gasoline Prices Are Up by Nearly a Quarter Since War Broke...
### Gas Prices and Iran Conflict (2026) U.S. average gas prices reached $4.18 per gallon on April 28, 2026, the highest since the Iran conflict began and since April 2022, per AAA data reported by UPI via Breitbart. This marked a 1.6% increase from $4.11 on April 27 and from $3.98 a month prior, a ...
In spring 2026, Fox News and affiliated outlets reported elevated U.S. gas prices linked to tensions and conflict in the Strait of Hormuz involving Iran. On April 18, 2026, Fox News Video featured GasBuddy analyst Matt McClain stating crude oil prices rose from $64.01 per barrel last year to $84 pe...

Writing analysis narrative

Analysis narrative ready

Narrative analysis generated

Writing verdict summary

Ratings generated

Investigation complete. Preparing report...

The Compass

You see how this outlet sees the world.

How do you see it? Find your political shape in a few minutes.

Take the test

Or check your own article